Five Acres Farm - Charm and Seclusion with 5 BR — Guest Reviews

Red Cottage5 bedrooms3 bathsSleeps 8

Review Summary

Overall Rating
5.0 / 5
Total Reviews
30
Sources
Airbnb (28) · Vrbo (2)
Most Recent
Jan 2026

Each review shows: source · star rating · date · guest comments. Reviews are grouped by traveler type. Persona ratings reflect the average score from guests in that category.

Ratings by Traveler Type

Families with Children
5.0 / 5
6 reviews
Friend Groups & Gatherings
5.0 / 5
6 reviews
Wedding Parties
5.0 / 5
1 review
Families with Children5.0 avg · 6 reviews
AirbnbJan 2026

Great location well preserved comfortable and spacious. Our family was happy here. Thank you

AirbnbOct 2025

We were looking for a place for several family members to stay while visiting relatives in Callicoon. This place was perfect. Three queen beds, two twin beds, three bathrooms. Everything clean and comfortable. Five minute drive to Callicoon business center. No hassles, no problems.

AirbnbAug 2025

This is a gorgeous farmhouse in an idyllic setting. The house itself is well appointed and was the perfect spot for our two families to spread out and relax. The kitchen had everything we needed to prepare elaborate meals for our large group. The house is situated near a few towns and is the perfect place for a fun and restful time in the Catskills. We liked the decor too! Thank you!

NiyamaVrboJul 2024

Excellent! Five Acres Farm was a wonderful retreat for our family vacation. The house was very well appointed and clean. We had everything we needed to cook meals, but town is close, so we had the option of going out as well. The property is quiet and serene. We would definitely stay here again!

AirbnbJul 2023

We stayed at Five Acres Farm with 4 adults and 3 children (1, 3, and 4 years old) and it was nearly perfect. The house and setting was absolutely beautiful and the house was clean and comfortable and had everything we needed. There were also plenty of fun things to do in the area. Our only concern was the temperature and maybe it was just unfortunate timing, but it was a hot and sticky long weekend and the house and bedrooms were too hot despite of using all fans provided. I didn’t deduct any stars for this as the description does state that there is no airconditioning. Also, if we didn’t have young children, we would have probably been out more and not have noticed it so much. I would still highly recommend this beautiful home in fun area though, just the temperature is just something to be mindful of, yet you will not regret your decision of booking this beautiful and spacious home.

AirbnbMay 2023

We absolutely loved our stay at 5 Acres Farm. Everything was as described and then some. My family enjoyed staying at this beautiful home. Looking forward to staying here again in the future.

Friend Groups & Gatherings5.0 avg · 6 reviews
AirbnbDec 2024

Beautiful house and perfect for a weekend away with friends.

AirbnbJul 2024

Great farm house for a large group (we were 7). The three full baths were welcome and the house had everything we needed to enjoy a relaxing weekend upstate.

AirbnbJan 2024

The cottage was beautiful and very private! My friends and I had a wonderful NYE weekend and felt that we had plenty of space. The kitchen was also fully stocked with appliances which made cooking for all of us quite easy!

AirbnbDec 2023

We had a great time staying here with our friends and dogs. Host is very responsive and place was clean and well stocked.

AirbnbDec 2023

Beautiful farm house in a secluded setting. We were a group of 5 women and it was so nice to each have our own bedroom plus 3 bathrooms. Very spacious, nicely updated and so peaceful. Crisp air and could see so many stars at night. Very close to the small towns of Callicoon and Jeffersonville. Cute shops and restaurants. If you are looking for an escape from the hustle and bustle to relax and unwind, this is the place to be!

AirbnbSep 2023

We enjoyed our stay at Red's Cottage. We were a group of 8, and the house was more than comfortable for our group. The house came equipped with all kitchen essentials, linens, soap etc. The surrounding area is beautiful, and there's plenty of activities in Sullivan County. I would recommend Red's Cottage to anyone looking for a getaway in upstate New York!

Wedding Parties5.0 avg · 1 review
AirbnbOct 2025

Five Acres Farm was a lovely place to stay to attend a wedding in Callicoon. The hosts were receptive and responded quickly to all inquiries. Cell phone service in the area is very spotty, so it can be difficult to get around with GPS cutting in and out, but the hosts notified us of this before our stay. The home was very clean and well maintained. Comfortable for a group of 8 for the weekend.

Anglers & Fishing Enthusiasts5.0 avg · 1 review
AirbnbJul 2024

Great place - we came for a concert at Bethel Woods and this is the perfect spot to access that, fishing, nearby towns, trails, lakes, etc. The property is beautiful. Would recommend.

Foodies & Culinary Explorers5.0 avg · 1 review
AirbnbAug 2023

Our stay at the farmhouse was stellar from start to finish with an extremely easy check in process. It was an enjoyable opportunity to enjoy the serene and secluded surroundings of the house, we spent nearly every day soaking up the sun in the beautiful land around the house. A short drive away you can find Callicoon center with excellent restaurants, breweries, distilleries right on UIpper Main St. The house is extremely spacious offering logistically great common rooms for chilling with your entire group as well as enough rooms and bathrooms for everyone to have their own space. It's an excellent home away from home to disconnect in the Catskills with everything you might need for your stay including BBQ grill.

All Reviews5.0 avg · 15 reviews
AirbnbSep 2025

Beautiful home and surroundings. Very peaceful. Enjoyed a beautiful weekend at this lovely home. Kitchen was very well stocked and lots to see and do in the surrounding towns. Lucked out with some perfect late summer weather too as a bonus. Highly recommend.

AirbnbJun 2025

Beautiful place, spacious and comfortable. Can’t wait to return.

AirbnbMay 2025

We had a great writing retreat here! Hopefully we'll be back at some point.

AirbnbDec 2024

Loved the place and the experience. Was the perfect get away from the city! Everything was as advertised and the team was very responsive.

AirbnbDec 2024

Great house and very responsive hosts. Much appreciated.

AirbnbNov 2024

We enjoyed our stay. The house was very clean and appeared just like the pictures. The beds were all comfortable and there were a lot of basic ingredients available. We would recommend the house to others looking for a tranquil and rustic retreat.

AirbnbOct 2024

Great!

AirbnbAug 2024

Everything was the way it said it would be. Had a good time thank you

AirbnbJan 2024

Quiet, peaceful, beautiful property with spacious, comfortable, very clean and well equipped farmhouse. The host is highly responsive, flexible and helpful. Perfect place to spend quiet happy time with family or friends. We intend to visit again soon and recommend Five Acres Farm without reservation. Kevin

AirbnbDec 2023

The property is beautiful, nestled in the bucolic landscape yet still a close drive to Callicoon and Jeffersonville. The house was older but well furnished and clean. The hosts were helpful and responsive. It was a great stay in a beautiful setting!

AirbnbOct 2023

This was a great stay. Fully stocked with everything we needed to retreat from the city.

AirbnbSep 2023

Love love the house. The hosts were amazing. The area is beautiful. Highly recommend.

AirbnbJul 2023

Great property for the Calicoon area. Host was easy to deal with.

JosieVrboJul 2023

Art & Charm This house was skillfully decorated & has all the charms the Catskills have to offer.

AirbnbMay 2023

Serene and relaxing! Loved the farmhouse and its breathtaking grounds! Very gracious home.

Check Availability & Book Direct

View rate calendar · Full listing · Reviews as of Jan 2026