Each review shows: source · star rating · date · guest comments. Reviews are grouped by traveler type. Persona ratings reflect the average score from guests in that category.
We booked this cabin for a surprise proposal for our friend, and it was absolutely the perfect place. The pictures truly don’t do it justice — the property is stunning in person. The decor and atmosphere were incredibly cozy yet worldly, creating such a special vibe for the entire stay.
The cabin had everything we needed, to the point where we didn’t even feel the need to leave. We cooked all of our meals, spent quality time in the different living spaces, and even enjoyed the hot tub while it was snowing. It was an unforgettable experience, and we couldn’t have asked for a better setting. Would love to be back during the different seasons.
Red Cottage was one the best AirBnBs we have stayed in. The location was stunning — private, gorgeous view, immaculate landscaping, and close to great restaurants and hikes.
The home was incredibly clean, well stocked, and had a very functional layout. The screened in porch made it the perfect place to relax for the week.
It accommodated our family, including young kids, very well. We did need to bring our own crib and kids supplies. (Not a negative, but parents should come prepared.)
The hosts were extremely responsive and addressed our small concerns very quickly. We would highly recommend this wonderful property and hope to visit again in the future. Thank you, Red Cottage, for the exceptional hospitality!
Just a beautiful space nestled in the Catskills. The view from the back yard is stunning. Everything felt very secluded yet accessible. Close to some great hiking trails. The home was very clean and cozy. We had a lovely stay.
This is one of the best Airbnbs I have stayed in. The location, the house, the decor, the garden, and the mountain view made this place perfect for a quiet, peaceful getaway. The house, especially the sunroom, gets a ton of natural sunlight. The host is prompt, responsive, and flexible with check-out time.
Minnewaska and Mohonk are within a 30-minute drive, and there are many outdoor breweries and orchards with fun activities for the kids.
We will definitely book this place again!
Had a lovely cozy weekend here. Beautiful home. Lovely view. Perfect weekend getaway.
Picturesque hot tub.
My only note would be I think the sign about the trash and recycling could be a bit cleared before having to ask / mentioning it at checkout. And from the pictures we didn't realize that one gorgeous room in the back of the house is screen doors not glass so you can't enjoy in the winter.
Other than those very small things it's a great place to stay! I'm sure it's absolutely breathtaking in the summer.
Our stay at Red Cottage was so peaceful and we felt instantly at home there. The landscaping was phenomenal with different species of trees and flowers in bloom and a perfectly situated hot tub perched in the middle of it all. We loved the indoor outdoor feel with big windows and a screened porch. Beds were very comfortable and the kitchen was well-stocked. We would definitely stay there again. A memorable time.
I've stayed at a lot of great Airbnbs. This is first time where I could actually see myself moving into this exact space.
The house and amenities were as described. The yard was beautifully landscaped with gorgeous views to make you not want to leave. The landscaping was so impeccably done. We sat admiring the different plans and shrubs. We got a few ideas for home. Location was perfect and close to all the activities we did. The host was responsive the 2 times we reached out. This house was definitely worth it and is on our list for future visits to the area.
Beautiful home with a stunning view. Highly recommend.
Very peaceful and relaxing. Perfect place to stay for a long weekend.
Gorgeous place and view of many honk area! Can’t wait to return- loved it
Had an amazing stay! Home and landscaping are beautiful and host was very responsive.
We had a mostly lovely time staying at this beautiful house in the woods. The views were impeccable, the kitchen was well stocked with high end, useful tools, and the location was exactly what we were looking for (remote feeling but close enough to conveniences). We were somewhat disappointed by our inability to use the downstairs (where the queen sized bed and family room was) for the majority of our trip due to the heat taking several days to warm up the space. The host did send the caretaker over but there wasn’t much he could do. Other than that, they helped clear the walk and driveway when we were hit by a snowstorm which was very much appreciated. All in all, it’s a gorgeous location, it just needs a little extra attention before guests arrive from its hosts in the winter time.