Duck Pond Lodge - Classic Log Charm with Private Hot Tub — Guest Reviews

Red Cottage3 bedrooms1 bathSleeps 5

Review Summary

Overall Rating
2.5 / 5
Total Reviews
5
Sources
Airbnb (5)
Most Recent
Jul 2026

Each review shows: source · star rating · date · guest comments. Reviews are grouped by traveler type. Persona ratings reflect the average score from guests in that category.

Ratings by Traveler Type

Luxury Seekers
2.5 / 5
1 review
Luxury Seekers2.5 avg · 1 review
ChristianAirbnbJan 2026

Such a wonderful spot, when can we come back? The cottage is the perfect getaway. Has everything you need for a cozy, restful trip the mountains. This authentic log cabin has all the amenities of a luxury hotel plus a wood stove, a stone fireplace and a well-stocked kitchen. The Red Cottage hosts were exceptionally responsive  and the location is pretty terrific, with a view of the Catskills and a creek running through the property. It’s an easy drive into Stone Ridge for restaurants and a good launch point for visiting other charming towns in the area.

All Reviews2.5 avg · 4 reviews
AirbnbJul 2026

I had such a lovely stay at this house! It is pristine, and beautifully and thoughtfully outfitted. The people who own this house have a high attention to detail and quality. For example, the shower products were really nice and there was a large selection of excellent teas. They didn't skimp. The decor is both minimalist but with a cheeky flair. Loved the light fixtures! I also appreciated that everything was "fool proof." The house was easy to get into, the coffee maker was easy to operate, and the air conditioner and TV were easy to turn on and off. Seems obvious but not all houses are like this! The hot tub as well was really nice and super clean. It was also a very peaceful stay; even though technically we weren't far from other houses, it was quiet and you couldn't see lights from other houses. It was easy to get into Kingston (about a 15 min drive). I would definitely recommend staying here!

AirbnbJul 2026

Such a lovely house! Everything was so intentional. Feels like a hidden gem.

AirbnbMay 2026

10/10 amazing city escape such a great property

GregAirbnbFeb 2026

The house was beautiful and the hosts were incredibly responsive. Would recommend.

Check Availability & Book Direct

View rate calendar · Full listing · Reviews as of Jul 2026