Catskills Retreat w/ Hot Tub, Swimming, Hiking — Guest Reviews

Red Cottage4 bedrooms2 bathsSleeps 8

Review Summary

Overall Rating
5.0 / 5
Total Reviews
43
Sources
Airbnb (43)
Most Recent
Apr 2026

Each review shows: source · star rating · date · guest comments. Reviews are grouped by traveler type. Persona ratings reflect the average score from guests in that category.

Ratings by Traveler Type

Friend Groups & Gatherings
5.0 / 5
6 reviews
Birthday Celebrants
5.0 / 5
2 reviews
Families with Children
5.0 / 5
2 reviews
Friend Groups & Gatherings5.0 avg · 6 reviews
AirbnbApr 2025

My friends and I stayed at Casa Magda for the weekend and loved every minute of it. The place is gorgeous and has everything you would need for a nice getaway. I would highly recommend staying here.

AirbnbFeb 2025

Great place to stay with a group. Very close to the mountain

AirbnbJan 2025

Beautiful location, great amenities, and in a great neighborhood. Everyone we met in the town were really kind. It was the perfect place to celebrate with my friends and experience my 30s.

AirbnbJan 2025

My friends and I go on 2 trips upstate a year and we all agreed that this space was the best one we have ever stayed in. It was so thoughtfully stocked and laid out. Everything was labelled clearly and all instructions sent were on point and helpful. I can’t say enough nice things about Casa Magda, would 100% come back.

AirbnbDec 2024

Amazing getaway with a group of friends for the weekend! The house is so beautifully decorated and designed. We enjoyed our cozy stay and can’t wait to come back.

AirbnbSep 2024

I can’t say enough good things about my stay here. I went with 5 girlfriends for my 40th birthday and we had the most magical time. The cabin has so many elements and areas to experience- from movie nights with the projector to relaxing in the hot tub after a very long hike to eating dinner together at the huge table and boogying under the disco ball. The home is beautifully styled with so many wonderful details and it’s all so high quality, no expense has been spared to make this place a next level experience. ✨✨✨

Birthday Celebrants5.0 avg · 2 reviews
AirbnbMay 2025

This place is an absolute dream. I booked this place for my 40th bday along with some of my best girl buds and we absolutely loved it - cooking in the well-equipped kitchen, dancing under the disco ball, flipping through records, watching a movie on the projector during a rainstorm - it was lovely. I’m pretty sure that Windham has a lot to offer but truthfully, we never left the property. My friends left during they felt like they’d been at a weekend retreat. This space is as good or better than the pics. We loved it!

AirbnbApr 2024

We celebrated a birthday weekend at Casa Magda and had a great time! The spot was remote and private and offered a great escape from city living. We did all of our own cooking in the beautiful kitchen which had all pots, pans, plates, silverware, glasses and cooking tools to serve 8 guests. The listed perks of the hot tub, disco ball, record player and heated bathrooms floors were all very easy to use. The house had several spaces to relax, eat and play games. We did not venture in to town on our trip bit did pass a small grocer on the way if you forgot any essentials. There were plenty of places close by to grab well priced firewood from. All in all we had a great trip and appreciated the ample space for 8 people.

Families with Children5.0 avg · 2 reviews
AirbnbApr 2025

We stayed here to celebrate my daughter’s 14th birthday and honestly, it was perfect. The place was super comfortable and had everything we needed to feel right at home. It was clean, cozy, and really well thought out. The disco lights made it everything, it added such a fun vibe to our stay. I’d definitely come back and totally recommend it.

AirbnbDec 2024

We had the best time here! It’s such a beautifully designed house, it’s a very smart house with so many cool tech features, such a great kitchen for cooking big family meals and the movie theatre is awesome. Would highly recommend!

Skiers & Snowboarders5.0 avg · 2 reviews
AirbnbNov 2024

We had a great time at this house! It has beautiful furnishings that matched the pictures, and great amenities like Bluetooth speakers, a hot tub and grill, and a fully stocked kitchen. It's like a practical piece of art! The instructions in the manual were very clear, check in was straightforward, and the host was very responsive to any questions we had. Close to the town of Windham for shopping and restaurants, as well as the ski mountain. We would definitely recommend this house, and would come back again.

AirbnbMar 2024

We stayed at Tiffany’s for a ski weekend at Hunter Mountain. The house was perfect for our group of ten. We would definitely stay with Tiffany again!

Bachelorette / Bachelor Parties5.0 avg · 2 reviews
AirbnbJul 2024

Perfect house for my friends bachelorette party. Plenty of space, well stocked kitchen and great backyard area. Decorated beautifully - we couldn’t have asked for a better house!

AirbnbMar 2024

Make travel plans around this cabin! I stayed here for my bachelorette and we never wanted to leave! So many fun things to do inside and such a beautiful space. No flack on the space or host, but do take her weather warnings seriously! My toyota corolla struggled getting up the big hill to the cabin in the snow. Tiffany, however, offered a ton a advice and help!

Foodies & Culinary Explorers5.0 avg · 1 review
AirbnbJun 2025

This place could not have been nicer. The best part was certainly how well equipped the kitchen was. We enjoyed making awesome dinners and utilizing the grill outside. The theater upstairs was alot of fun. We will definitely be back

Couples5.0 avg · 1 review
AirbnbJan 2025

We booked Casa Magda for a quiet start to the New Year. The design elements in the listing spoke to us and our aesthetic, and we were thoroughly pleased to be there. It was just two of us although the home is built for many more. While there, I found myself dreaming of future visits with friends or family. It is definitely a place I would like to return. We enjoyed all of the amenities, fully stocked kitchen, fireplace, hot tub and the giant movie screen and viewing loft. Because it is situated near three ski hills there is just enough retail nearby in case you forget anything, but it was also quiet enough to be a 'real' getaway. The added bonus of the disco lights were more magical than we could have imagined.

Nature Lovers5.0 avg · 1 review
AirbnbNov 2024

A lovely stay and beautiful location, secluded with a large yard and fire pit where we spent a night stargazing. Not to mention the fantastically cozy living area and projector to lounge and relax. Thank you!

Large Groups 8+5.0 avg · 1 review
AirbnbMay 2024

Casa Magda was such a lovely! Our group of 8 had an amazing time relaxing in the hot tub, hiking in the surrounding area, enjoying the beautiful space. Wonderful kitchen and great outdoor spaces. The host provided excellent recommendations via their listing website and was responsive to questions.

Business Travelers5.0 avg · 1 review
AirbnbApr 2024

I stayed at Red Cottage with a group of coworkers in April 2024 and we had an amazing time! The house is so trendy and well thought out. We found the space to be very functional for a group getaway. The amenities like hot tub, fireplace, and sound system were stellar, and the disco ball was a fun addition! Highly recommend this property for a stylish & luxurious retreat! Ps- mattresses were on the firm side, but I didn’t mind!

Girls' Trip5.0 avg · 1 review
AirbnbMar 2024

Casa Magda exceeded all our expectations! From the moment we arrived, we were blown away by the attention to detail. It's easily the most well-equipped Airbnb we've ever stayed in, with every essential and convenience thoughtfully provided - from kitchen tools like bottle openers and peelers to a variety of pans for cooking. Tiffany, our host, was incredibly welcoming and accommodating. The house itself was a haven of comfort and style. Impeccably decorated, spacious, and spotlessly clean, it offered a truly aesthetic retreat. The pleasant aroma throughout the house added to the ambiance. Our girls' trip was transformed into an unforgettable experience at Casa Magda. We indulged in a spontaneous dance party beneath the disco ball, enjoyed movie nights, and enjoyed glasses of wine by the cozy bonfire. Exploring the serene surroundings and taking leisurely walks down the road added to the tranquility of our stay. Leaving Casa Magda was bittersweet - we simply didn't want to leave.

All Reviews5.0 avg · 23 reviews
AirbnbApr 2026

This space is really beautiful. You can tell the homeowner created it as a truly special project. The home itself is renovated beautifully and it has gorgeous furniture and everything you could want in the kitchen’s bathrooms and deck. It has an amazing fire pit outside and a great hot tub. The projector room is really fun to watch movies. And they have every little thing you could need. I will say it’s the nicest place. We have stayed in terms of their design and interior. Highly recommend and the host was the most responsive we have brought with. They respond in minutes and are very easy to work with.

AirbnbApr 2026

Its a splurge but so worth the stay! The home is well maintained and thanks to the care taken by the owner it's easy to honor the intentional and well curated vibe. The kitchen is well equipped so you can stay close to "home" enjoying the fire, hot-tub and the big screen for movies. Breathtaking and challenging hikes and more to explore nearby. I've stayed here twice and will easily be back again.

AirbnbFeb 2026

Loved staying here. The house has everything you could need.

AirbnbJan 2026

We enjoyed our stay very much. The home was beautiful and the location was very convenient to Windham and everything it has to offer. The host was very responsive whenever we had an issue or a question. We would highly recommend.

AirbnbNov 2025

This home was lovely!

AirbnbOct 2025

We loved our stay at Casa Magda! It's a wonderful house with an extraordinarily beautiful design and a well equipped kitchen.

AirbnbSep 2025

Already plotting our return :’) Incredible space. So comfortable, felt like we were staying at a friends house. It was a dream <3

AirbnbAug 2025

Wonderful stay! Beautiful, well-appointed home in a really nice location. Great selection of art, records and music. I would definitely stay here again

AirbnbAug 2025

We had the best time at casa Magda and felt well taken care of with really good communication all throughout the trip. So happy to spend one of the last few weekends of summer 2025 here!

AirbnbJul 2025

great stay. super clean and comfortable. really responsive and helpful host.

AirbnbMar 2025

We had such a lovely time. Thank you for hosting us and we hope to come back!

AirbnbJan 2025

We had a relaxing and wonderful stay. The house was cozy and perfect for enjoying downtime. We all slept well in the cozy bedrooms, loved watching shows on the projector and the disco ball at night was magical. The surrounding area was peaceful and quiet and the hot tub at night was the perfect way to enjoy the out of doors.

AirbnbDec 2024

Most ideal place for a getaway trip!

AirbnbOct 2024

Thank you, beautiful place !

AirbnbOct 2024

This was our second stay at this beautiful property. The house exudes so much coolness and calm. It’s incredibly cozy and comfortable and you can tell how much thought was put into every detail. The addition of the hot tub has brought the stay to another level. We can’t say enough how breathtaking the surrounding landscape is… truly something you have to experience in your lifetime. We already can’t wait to come back for another weekend! Thank you to Tiffany for opening her incredible space to us.

AirbnbOct 2024

It was an amazing stay at a beautiful home.. picture perfect .. exactly what we needed

AirbnbOct 2024

The home was beautiful, charming and very clean. The upgrades that were made to the home were amazing. The bathrooms were nice and the floors were heated. Everything was labeled so we never had questions. We would love to visit again! Exactly like the photos. Highly recommended.

AirbnbAug 2024

We had an amazing experience in this Cottage, host is great and the cottage has all the amenities that you need, everything was clean and comfortable. Thank you!

AirbnbAug 2024

Pretty nice

AirbnbJul 2024

We enjoyed our stay here. The movie screen/projector was fun, and we enjoyed using the hot tub and fire pit. The home was clean and communication with management was terrific.

AirbnbJun 2024

This is the most gorgeous airbnb I have stayed at, the design of each room is beautiful and the whole house has many entertaining items including games, karaoke, and so much more fun stuff! We all loved the home and had so much fun, the back patio is big and the yard is beautiful, very big and beautiful had a great time, owner was cooperative and the home was easy to find! 10/10! Would definitely go again!

AirbnbJun 2024

We loved our stay! Thank you for having us at your beautiful home.

AirbnbMay 2024

The house was absolutely gorgeous with plenty of space for everyone to stay. The kitchen has everything we needed to cook and make coffee while we were there. We enjoyed time in the hot tub and were grateful for the swim towels provided. The location makes it perfect for a weekend getaway! All check in and check out instructions were clear and we enjoyed some of the local recommendations listed in the welcome book.

Check Availability & Book Direct

View rate calendar · Full listing · Reviews as of Apr 2026