Cabin by Clover Pond | Hot Tub, Private Pond, 7 Acres — Guest Reviews

Red Cottage2 bedrooms1 bathSleeps 4

Review Summary

Overall Rating
4.5 / 5
Total Reviews
36
Sources
Airbnb (36)
Most Recent
Oct 2026

Each review shows: source · star rating · date · guest comments. Reviews are grouped by traveler type. Persona ratings reflect the average score from guests in that category.

All Reviews4.5 avg · 36 reviews
GuestAirbnbOct 2026

This place is perfect for a weekend getaway. It is exactly as depicted and cozy, clean and comfortable. Hosts are very communicative and respond relatively quickly. Just be sure to confirm exact check in instructions before arrival!

GuestAirbnbSep 2026

We loved staying in Roscoe! We were vacationing with 2 children (1 year old and 5 year old) and spent hours up at the pond. We had such a good time and no one wanted to leave!

GuestAirbnbSep 2026

Great little cozy cabin! The hot tub was amazing, everything was clean and comfortable, and we had a wonderful stay. Would definitely recommend!

GuestAirbnbAug 2026

Great stay great host!

GuestAirbnbJul 2026

My partner and I both loved this cute stay. I loved the kitchen and the decor was so cozy and inviting. We felt right at home as soon as we entered. I would love to come back here in the future.

GuestAirbnbJul 2026

We absolutely loved our stay. Super peaceful location and the house was very clean and comfortable

GuestAirbnbJul 2026

Na

GuestAirbnbJul 2026

Enjoyed our stay in Roscoe. The interior was in great shape and the hot tub was a lovely amenity. Convenient location to Roscoe and Livingston Manor which both had great shops, restaurants and hiking trails.

GuestAirbnbJun 2026

My lady and I enjoyed the trip a lot. Thank you for the amazing experience

GuestAirbnbJun 2026

Quiet location very close to town, i would return again. Hosts were very responsive if we had a question. Clean and modern inside.

GuestAirbnbJun 2026

Had a great stay. Place was clean and matched the description for the property. Host was very responsive and proactive. Conveniently located close to Roscoe, NY for local activities.

GuestAirbnbJun 2026

I was so excited for my weekend stay but was sadly extremely disappointed upon arrival. First, when I inquired about early check in, they wanted to nickel and dime me requesting an extra $50 for early check in. Once I arrived I was appalled at the condition. There was a large hole in the exterior that they attempted to cover with tape, the paint was peeling everywhere. The weed were growing so tall they reached my knees. One dock for the lake was floating away and the other dock area looked corroded. The exterior chairs and tables were dirty and looked so old I don't think they could support the weight of an adult. Inside, wasn't much better. The bathroom sink fixture was peeling, the base boards were pulling away from the wall. The fridge was dented, an outlet was broken exposing the internal electrical wires. And, while I know this is not a necessity most Airbnbs have some sort of welcome package. This place had nothing, not even the WiFi network or password available (printed form).

GuestAirbnbJun 2026

We had a great stay at the home. The home was clean and just what we were looking for. Our favorite part of the home was the hot tub, which we ended every night in after a long day of fly fishing.

GuestAirbnbMay 2026

We really enjoyed our stay at what we called the “Roscoe Retreat”! It was beautiful and peaceful. Exactly what we were hoping for. We really enjoyed the hot tub and the privacy. We explored the town which included the Roscoe Diner and Northern Family Pasta which we loved so much! We enjoyed using the kitchen and cooking at “home” as well. It was peaceful all day and night. We would highly recommend to anyone looking for a cute, relaxing and refreshing getaway!

GuestAirbnbMay 2026

Beautiful stay! We loved the hot tub and the couch was AMAZING!! Which was good because it was very rainy! Great family getaway despite the weather. Grill worked great, comfy beds, excellent communication from the hosts. Make sure you note the WiFi password before you arrive because there was only SOS until we were able to connect. Will seek these hosts’ properties out again.

GuestAirbnbMay 2026

The location of the property is perfect; a few minutes to the town of Roscoe, 12 min to Livingston Manor, 25 min to Jeffersonville or 15 min to Callicoon. The house looked exactly like the listing. It was clean, cozy and comfortable. The kitchen was well-equipped, had everything we needed to cook meals everyday. The property includes a private pond, outdoor sitting area by the pond and the fire pit. We enjoyed our morning coffee and evening sunset-gazing there. It is such a beautiful scenery. We enjoyed this property very much!

GuestAirbnbMay 2026

Me encanto in lugar muy agenda le para desconectarse

GuestAirbnbMay 2026

We had a wonderful stay at this place. The location is pretty secluded, offering a perfect forest retreat. The jacuzzi was a fun highlight, and the house was fully stocked with all the kitchen supplies and amenities. The fireplace had plenty of firewood, and the Wi-Fi worked perfectly. Communication with the host was also very fast and smooth. We will definitely come back again.

GuestAirbnbMay 2026

Fantastic stay! Everything was great!

GuestAirbnbApr 2026

I really loved this place. The cabin is fully private and separate, so you can truly relax without any noise or disturbance. The beautiful lake nearby and the peaceful atmosphere made it even more special. Restaurants are also just a 5-minute drive away, which is very convenient. I want to say a big thank you to the people who created this amazing place for others to enjoy and feel comfortable. Everywhere I went, I met kind and welcoming people. Wishing you continued success in this wonderful work!

GuestAirbnbMar 2026

Beautiful, peaceful space in the Catskill Mountains. The home was extremely clean & beautifully arranged for my wife and I to feel comfortable at home. The Jacuzzi is a wonderful, all appliances work. I would definitely book again. The only nitpick is, on arrival, the access code that I was given didn’t work and I had to call the owners for a backup code to get on the house.

GuestAirbnbMar 2026

Had a great stay in Roscoe. Other than some minor issues with the door upon arrival, wifi, and stove, our stay was great. Very communicative hosts.

GuestAirbnbMar 2026

Cute and cozy place. Everything was great and we loved the hot tub!

GuestAirbnbFeb 2026

We had a very enjoyable getaway and truly loved our stay! The place was clean, comfortable, and exactly what we needed for a relaxing escape. The hot tub was a huge highlight, perfect for unwinding and the grill was great as well. We really enjoyed cooking out and spending time outside. The only small hiccup was some difficulty getting in with the entry code at first, but it was resolved shortly after and everything went smoothly from there. Overall, a great experience and we’d definitely come back!

GuestAirbnbFeb 2026

Nice and comfortable, well equipped kitchen, easy access, very responsible management, quiet area. I think maybe somewhat overpriced and while it has been renovated, some time has already passed.

GuestAirbnbFeb 2026

nice

GuestAirbnbFeb 2026

The house was warm, cozy, and was exactly what was described. It was incredible. It would’ve been perfect if it wasn’t for check-in and post check-out. When we first arrived it was 0 degrees outside, the code they provided for the front door did not work. Then I was told there was a lock box in the back yard with a physical key. The lockbox was impossible to open and after standing in the freezing cold I finally got it open and there was no key. I had to call them to get an alternate code, it was really cold and took a while. And then 2 hours after we checked out and started heading home, I received a text that I had left something at the house and was told I could go back and get it. I took the 2 hour drive back to the house and then was told that they can’t give it to me and only ship it. I had wasted a lot of time and money. They eventually told me I didn’t have to pay for shipping and got a refund. All in all, it was not very professional checking in and then returning my item.

GuestAirbnbJan 2026

What a beautiful home and location! This place looked just like the pictures. The hot tub was amazing and clean. The staff were super helpful and responded quickly. They even accommodated an early check in. The one downside is the driveway wasn't plowed when we arrived but thanks to a helpful neighbor, a plow truck did come on the 2nd day. You definitely need snow tires and 4 wheel drive to visit in the winter. We had everything we needed to cook. The bed was super comfy and so was the couch, just a little low for us getting up and down. We felt right at home. When we got stuck in the snow in the driveway, the neighbor across the street and the cleaning person for the home were super helpful. I highly recommend this place for a peaceful, relaxing, and secluded stay. The staff were super accommodating and attentive. I would definitely book again.

GuestAirbnbJan 2026

Great place — cozy, quiet, and very comfortable. Everything was perfect, and I really enjoyed my stay. Highly recommend!

GuestAirbnbJan 2026

Cute, quaint house with beautiful views! The house itself is charming and has a great layout. While it’s smaller than the pictures might suggest, the living room, kitchen, and bathroom are very spacious. The bedrooms are sufficient for two people each, but storage is extremely limited—there are no dressers and barely any space to hang clothes, so I recommend coming prepared to live out of your suitcase. Owners, a suggestion would be to use the wall space in these rooms for additional storage for clothes and travel items. The house has lovely amenities, including a hot tub, which we really enjoyed. We visited in the winter, but I can only imagine how beautiful the area must be in spring or summer for hiking and enjoying the pond. A word of caution: if you have children, be careful around the pond—it was snow-covered when we visited, and it’s easy to mistake the land for the pond as it’s very close to the house. The local area has some limitations, but we were able to find yummy food

GuestAirbnbDec 2025

The house looks nice overall and had everything we needed for our stay. The kitchen was well equipped, which made things very convenient, and the space was comfortable. The listing mentions that the property was recently renovated; however, some details like the molding, tiles, and general finishing could be better maintained or done more carefully. We also noticed that some areas could have been cleaner — for example, the rugs and couch were a bit dusty, and our towels were left in the dryer when we arrived. Overall, it was a good stay, but considering the price, the cleanliness and attention to detail could be improved.

GuestAirbnbDec 2025

Had a wonderful time!

GuestAirbnbDec 2025

Amazing value, definitely rebooking!

GuestAirbnbDec 2025

Me and my partner loved this small town and space. It was super cozy and secluded which we really enjoyed especially coming from NYC. The hot tub was excellent and felt amazing. The only hiccup was the door code but that was resolved with customer service in 5 min. I would come back again!

GuestAirbnbNov 2025

the house was perfect for what we were looking for. loved the hot tub! the only reason I gave it a 4 star was bc thr oven and stove didn't work and we had planned to spend the time cooking. luckily my partner is a chef and we were able to pivot and use the bbq.

GuestAirbnbOct 2025

Peaceful & comfortable

Check Availability & Book Direct

View rate calendar · Full listing · Reviews as of Oct 2026