Wildcat Mountain Cabin - Private, Views w/ Hot Tub — Guest Reviews

Red Cottage2 bedrooms2 bathsSleeps 4

Review Summary

Overall Rating
4.9 / 5
Total Reviews
43
Sources
Airbnb (36) · Vrbo (7)
Most Recent
Apr 2026

Each review shows: source · star rating · date · guest comments. Reviews are grouped by traveler type. Persona ratings reflect the average score from guests in that category.

Ratings by Traveler Type

Couples
5.0 / 5
5 reviews
Hikers & Trail Enthusiasts
4.6 / 5
5 reviews
Pet Owners
5.0 / 5
4 reviews
Couples5.0 avg · 5 reviews
AmyVrboMar 2026

The perfect winter getaway for my boyfriend and I. Private and cozy. Will definitely be back.

KellyVrboSep 2025

My husband and I were just in need of some quiet time not too far from Long Island. That is exactly what we got. The cabin was immaculate, cozy, quiet, and peaceful. We will definitely be coming back!

AirbnbMar 2025

My wife and I had an amazing time here. The place is cozy and well equipped for a comfortable stay. It was great to relax in the hot tub after a long hike and then rest by the fireplace, or to enjoy the sunrise flowing into the master bedroom on a cold February day. The hosts were diligent and available. They provided precise instructions on how to get to the cabin and how to operate its various features. Would love to come back here again, but maybe during the summer this time!

AirbnbJun 2024

My husband and I couldn't have imagined a better spot for our 10-year wedding anniversary. The house was beautiful and filled with so many gorgeous antiques/details. The view was spectacular, visible from nearly every room! The outdoor seating on the patio, firepit, and meadow were where we spent most of our time. The wildlife was breathtaking. We had two turkeys fly over our heads, which is a definite first. Stargazing in the hottub was a dream!!! It was so helpful to have the written directions on hand as well as the local shop lists. They do not exaggerate about the road, get a 4x4 for it. The only downside was my fault. I forgot to ask if the pillows were down feathers, as I'm allergic. Luckily, I had antihistamines and the pillows in the second bedroom were polyfill. We've only been home for a few hours and are already planning our trip back.

AirbnbNov 2023

A wonderful secluded cabin with the right amenities and size for 2 people. Would recommend to anyone and would definitely go back again. No complaints whatsoever, it was perfect. Thank you for a great time!

Hikers & Trail Enthusiasts4.6 avg · 5 reviews
AirbnbSep 2025

a wonderful experience in a well appointed cabin. we particularly enjoyed the seclusion and peaceful environment. The hot-tub was great! especially after a long hike! The grounds and property were beautiful and blended in with nature and the surrounding forest. We highly recommend this secluded cabin!

AirbnbDec 2024

If the question is would we go back, than the answer is yes. The place was perfect. So relaxing and just a nice change of scenery from the busy city. The hikiing trail were beautiful as well. We cant wait to go back. Take the fime and get away, you'll enjoy the Red Cottage

AirbnbNov 2024

Overall, our stay was pleasant, and the house is nice, but it does have some issues. 1. The house has a rodent problem. There are mice living in the house. We heard them on the first night in the ceiling and walls. The second night, we saw a mouse behind the wood stove crawl up into the ceiling. We also returned from a hike to find mouse droppings on one of the beds. I understand that it’s a house in the woods, and these things happen, but the owners or caretakers need to address the pest problem. 2. Most of the dishes and flatware were dirty. I understand they probably rely on the prior guests to hand-clean and put them away, but they should really have the caretakers do some sort of double-check so that it’s not on us to clean the dishes we want to use when we arrive. 3. We couldn’t get the oven to work. I’m fairly sure the oven is broken, but it’s possible we just had trouble getting it to work. The caretakers did offer to send a handyman to take a look, but we decided against it.

AirbnbMar 2024

It was exactly what we needed. Wanted a cabin in the woods away from it all. The coziness of the home was so relaxing. The hot tub was amazing after a long hike. The stove warmed us very quickly. It was an amazing getaway that was surely needed! Would love to make this a yearly trip. Thank you!

AirbnbAug 2023

Extremely cozy stay. Everything was super clean. It felt like home. The kitchen is stocked with everything you could possibly need. Bedrooms were extremely clean and the master bathroom was amazing. Toilet with heated seat and a bidet. The amenities were top-notch. We LOVED the hot tub!! Especially after a long day of hiking. The view from the backyard is gorgeous. So serene and peaceful. We saw plenty of deer and even some turkeys. This place is a hidden gem. Thank you so much for having us, we will be back!

Pet Owners5.0 avg · 4 reviews
AirbnbJan 2026

The house was perfect and we felt right at home with our doggie. They have so many wonderful books - i wish i could have stayed longer. The surrounding land was a perfect snowy landscape - so the hot tub did add i nice layer of warmth to the place. The amenities added an excellent dimension to the stay - alowung us to pamper ourselves. The morning walks with our furry companion, allowed us to get a bit of excercise and enjoy the cold crisp air. We went to Peekamoose resto, its about 45 minutes away, which was unexpectidly wonderul. Alround great spot if you like rest and being in nature, and the warm cabin helped us acclimate easily to the winter wonderland that surrounded us. Prepare to bring and make food as resto are about 30 to 45 minutes away.

AirbnbSep 2024

This place was the perfect spot for my friends and our doggos. Very dog friendly and so much space outside to run around! For the humans, the hot tub was amazing, especially surrounded by the beautiful mountains in the crispy fall air. I also recommend the outdoor shower!!

AirbnbOct 2023

Beautiful property, great for dogs and great for hot tubbing under the fall leaves. Will stay again.

AirbnbJul 2023

Amazing space. Nice, secluded area perfect for dogs to run around. Looking forward to our next visit!

Holiday Gatherers5.0 avg · 2 reviews
AirbnbJan 2026

we really enjoyed our holiday at this house and will be back!

AirbnbDec 2025

Red Cottage provided exactly what we were looking for on our Thanksgiving getaway- cozy relaxation, great views & lots of land.

Nature Lovers4.5 avg · 2 reviews
AirbnbFeb 2025

We had a lovely time! We especially enjoyed the hottub and woodstove! It was pretty snowy so we didn’t leave the property but we really enjoyed a snowy walk through the woods around the house and the host came to plow us out the morning we were leaving and were very communicative about that.

AirbnbJul 2024

Sweet cabin in a private, beautiful location. We loved sitting on the porch and watching the deer, as well as the outdoor shower and hot tub! We arrived just as it was getting dark so missed the turn for the driveway at first, but were able to double back pretty easily.

Romantic Getaway5.0 avg · 1 review
AirbnbFeb 2026

Our stay at The Red Cottage for Valentines weekend was everthing we imagined. It was secluded and private without being difficult to find. The inside soaking tub was a dreamy way to start the morning and the hot tub felt so nice against the winter air, especially followed by a cow in the gorgeous wood stove. Mountain views were beautiful and we hope to come back when it’s warmer to enjoy some outdoor activities as well! The house was clean, stocked with wood and all the basics. Thank you Red Cottage!

Outdoor & Adventure Seekers5.0 avg · 1 review
AaronVrboSep 2025

Great getaway! The cabin had great vibes, nearby trails are beautiful, and the hot tub was perfect for watching the stars at night.

Remote Work Stay4.0 avg · 1 review
AirbnbOct 2023

The cabin is beautiful and rustic but with modern amenities, especially the hot tub! The setting is beautiful and quiet and peaceful. The only problem was no WiFi which affected one of us who expected to work remotely and therefore delayed coming up.

All Reviews4.9 avg · 22 reviews
AirbnbApr 2026

lovely spacious cottage with all the comforts and luxurious you need.

AirbnbFeb 2026

We felt at home, cozy and comfortable. The atmosphere and beauty of the cabin were amazing. The accommodations were perfect and everything fell into place as it should! The mountainside views are beautiful and the space and seclusion are unmatched. I can't wait to experience another season of the year here.

AirbnbJan 2026

It was an incredible stay, so serene and isolated. Perfect for some rest and relaxation. Hot tub is so worth it

AirbnbNov 2025

We just got home from a wonderful long weekend at the cabin! The location and the place itself were 10/10. I can’t say enough good things about our time spent here. The cabin was beautifully maintained and had more amenities than expected! We especially loved the hot tub and the wood burning stove. Incredible views and beautiful property.

AirbnbJul 2025

beautiful stay, very peaceful. thank you!

RyanVrboMay 2025

Weekend getaway Peaceful and beautiful if you want quiet time

AirbnbMay 2025

Great place to stay. Beautiful setting off the beaten track. We had a great weekend.

AirbnbFeb 2025

Beautiful cabin. The kitchen has a pan for anything you could think to make, the private views had us daydreaming of what it must look like in every season and making plans on when we could come back!

AirbnbDec 2024

Wonderful stay in snowy winter wonderland! Host was super responsive and went above and beyond to help! The road was plowed and the house had everything you need.

AnonymousVrboNov 2024
BenjaminVrboNov 2024
AirbnbOct 2024

Absolutely beautiful place!

DhruvitVrboAug 2024
AirbnbFeb 2024

Very peaceful! The smell of cedar when I walked in was amazing. Everything I needed was in the cabin and more. Stargazing, movie nights, great place to cook, relaxing. It’s what I was looking for

AirbnbJan 2024

A cozy whimsical cabin with all the modern amenities you'll need to be comfortable. It is secluded and I would recommend a 4x4 for the driveway to the property.

AirbnbDec 2023

Awesome place and super cozy. The jacuzzi was amazing and it feels like quintessential Upstate NY.

AirbnbOct 2023

Second time staying here - had an amazing time.

AirbnbOct 2023

The weekend was great. Although we were only there for a couple of nights, it was a great getaway in a clean house with fantastic amenities like their hot tub (great for star gazing at night too). Felt very cozy and right at home. The Red Cottage contacts were extremely responsive to any questions that popped up and overall enjoyed our stay a lot. Would definitely recommend.

AirbnbSep 2023

Great location and home

AirbnbSep 2023

We loved our stay in this cabin. It was very private, very well decorated, peaceful and enjoyable. Stargazing in the hottub was a unique experience. The host was very responsive and communicated very clearly and friendly. We would love to come back!

AirbnbAug 2023

I loved this place. Incredibly private, quiet & serene it’s the perfect getaway to unplug. The cottage had everything we needed and was very comfortable and airy. And the hot tub was spacious and well maintained. Highly recommend this place for an upstate trip.

AirbnbJul 2023

Wow, what a wonderful place to get away! This lovely cabin had everything we needed and was the perfect place to relax and unwind from busy city life. We were lucky to see so many sweet deer and rabbits enjoying the outdoors as much as we were and we’d definitely stay again in the future! It was so nice, private, and peaceful; and stargazing in the hot tub was pretty exceptional. Highly recommend!

Check Availability & Book Direct

View rate calendar · Full listing · Reviews as of Apr 2026