Stony Shore Cabin - Charming cabin from yesteryear β€” Guest Reviews

Simple Life Rentals2 bedrooms1 bathSleeps 6

Review Summary

Overall Rating
4.8 / 5
Total Reviews
22
Sources
Vrbo (11) Β· Airbnb (11)
Most Recent
Oct 2026

Each review shows: source Β· star rating Β· date Β· guest comments. Reviews are grouped by traveler type. Persona ratings reflect the average score from guests in that category.

All Reviews4.8 avg Β· 22 reviews
TracyVrboOct 2026

Very nice quite place to stay. Close to everything. View beautiful!

GuestAirbnbOct 2026

This place is GREAT! The shower just might be the best thing but then you can’t beat the views of the bay.

GuestAirbnbOct 2026

A great spot to stay during our Door County trip!

GuestAirbnbSep 2026

This is more what I would call a fishing cabin. The bedrooms are small, just enough room to walk around the beds. The kitchen is more of a kitchenette. The bathroom is pretty spacious, though and we appreciated that. Overall, the cabin is rustic and felt very Wisconsiny and nostalgic. Very clean and no bugs! 😊

AmberVrboSep 2026

Cute little property that will bring back a nostalgia of a simpler time visiting your family's lake cabin growing up. Relaxing lake shore property to disconnect for awhile. Easily get to all that door county has to offer. Driveway has room for backing in a 22ft boat if your bringing one along. If you plan on grilling bring grilling utensils and charcoal. The kitchen had most everything else you'll need otherwise. Perfect couple getaway, 2 couples or a small family. With the tight space I'd say it sleeps 2-4 adults over just an occupancy of 6. Unless you got a little kid or younger person with no aches and pains yet, who can sleep on the pull out love seat. Living room sleepers will be awake when someone goes to the bathroom, to make coffee or wants to get out to the porch to enjoy their coffee and the morning sounds.The back yard has a firpit and a couple chairs, bring extra if there are more than 2 people. Great location and greater times had!

JulienneVrboSep 2026

The cabin was VERY CLEAN...small but clean. The major disappointment was the view. We booked it for a view of the Bay...what we got was a view of all the trees and undergrowth that BLOCKED the view of the water. Trimming up the trees and chopping back all the undergrowth is in order!!That goes for the 911 address marker, too....Completely buried in tree growth so not very visible from road!!!

SteveVrboAug 2026
GuestAirbnbAug 2026

Place was exactly what I expected and what we were looking for

ThereseVrboAug 2026

Nice location but could use updating (inside and outside). Very overgrown ground cover. Driveway was very dark and overgrown, hard to find. Inside was cozy but outdated. Screen porch was ok, but we didn’t use it. Bathroom was ok, but shower was small and the sink took a very long time to drain. This spot was more rustic than we anticipated.

SarahVrboAug 2026

Wr had such a lovely time at Stony Shore Cabin. We wanted a waterfront cabin experience and it did not disappoint! The view was stunning and we had everything we needed in the cabin. Worth the price alone was the screened in porch, where we played games, had coffee, watched the sunset and recharged. Thank you!

GuestAirbnbJun 2026

Jeff and Debbie couldn’t be sweeter. The fact they let you share such a beautiful piece of Door County is more than enough! The cabin (hand built) offers the best access and views of the water, has the coziest feel, and is the perfect place to take in the scenery.

GuestAirbnbOct 2025

Great place on the bay!

GuestAirbnbJul 2025

β˜€οΈπŸ™‚

GuestAirbnbJul 2025

We loved our stay in this cabin. The highlights were the screened in porch, the deck overlooking the lake, and the easy access to the lakeshore. The property was very clean, cozy, and quiet. Easy to get to all of Door County's attractions. We would definitely stay here again!

GuestAirbnbJul 2025

We had a lovely stay and greatlyenjoyed the lake views and setting. We were surprised that the place was smaller and much older than the pictures suggested. Easy check-in and clear instructions for check out.

GuestAirbnbJun 2025

This is a very clean, rustic little cabin. The sunsets were great. We enjoyed our stay.

GuestAirbnbJun 2025

We had a great stay here! The beautiful sunsets over the lake were definitely the high point. The cabin was peaceful and had everything we needed. We’d love to come back!

RachelVrboDec 2024

Family Trip Very nice

TaraVrboSep 2024

Amazing spot! We rented this cottage to celebrate our 25th anniversary, it was perfect. Loved the location and rocky beach for sunsets. So cool to read about family history of the place, several pictures hanging in bathroom of cottage being built and family spending time there. Cottage was built in 50s but maintained well and clean.

AnonymousVrboSep 2024

Faulty Lockbox It was dark when we arrived and it was hard to find the lockbox. After we opened the cabin, we were unable to reattach the lockbox to the bracket. Several attempts were made to contact the property manager to get instructions.

AnonymousVrboAug 2024

Stoney shore Great stay!

LAURAVrboAug 2024

Stony Shore in July We had a great week at Stony Shore cabin. Cute cabin, knotty pine throughout, loved the screen porch. When we arrived on Sunday afternoon it was a very hot day. We were pleasantly surprised that the cabin had been updated with air conditioning! πŸŽ‰ A couple minor suggestions/additions, a night light in the bathroom, an extra house key & expansion of the parking area. We had two full sized pickups and it was difficult to get turned around/parked so we didn’t have to back out onto the highway. On days when our group went two different directions it would have been handy to have two(2) house keys. Overall we enjoyed our stay. A full sized fridge was nice, kitchen was well stocked with dishes/pots and pans. Comfortable beds and pillows. Pullout couch came in handy to get a distance away from snoring housemates. πŸ˜‰ Thanks for a fun week in Door County.

Check Availability & Book Direct

View rate calendar Β· Full listing Β· Reviews as of Oct 2026