Reservoir House - Stylish and Peaceful in Roscoe — Guest Reviews

My friends and I loved staying here! Would definitely come back again.

A perfect weekend getaway with friends! So relaxing and the surrounding towns were had great restaurant options and little shops. Our heat broke which was unfortunate, but Red Cottage was so responsive and helped find alternative ways to fix the furnace.

We had a great stay at Red Cottage. The house itself was cozy, beautifully decorated, and surrounded by nature. Really nice relaxing getaway with friends. A few notes worth mentioning. The house wasn't stocked with essentials like salt or coffee, which was frustrating as shops aren't that close to the accommodation and were closed in the evening when we arrived - after already having done a grocery shop. We found appliances not properly cleaned, two of which had living bugs and mold inside, as well as dirty crockery in the cupboards. We let the company know during our stay but unfortunately found their response dismissive and indifferent.

Great place to stay in the Catskills. Perfect for a weekend getaway. Lots of hiking and nature. The place is well furnished and well decorated. Would highly recommend this stay!

The home was beautiful and in an idyllic location. We wish we could have spent more time there. Great options for skiing nearby.

We had a wonderful stay at Red Cottage over the New Year’s holiday. House was beautifully decorated and well stocked with all the essentials. Great communication from hosts who provided clear, detailed instructions for a seamless check-in/check-out. As others have mentioned, it can be tricky to find the house– definitely recommend downloading the map beforehand as service is quite spotty in the area. Overall great stay, the house provided us with the perfect quiet getaway over the holidays!

Beautiful home to have a quiet weekend away. The couch is absolutely amazing spent quality time with my teens watching movies.

it was great. thank you.

What a magnificent home and location. The hosts are incredibly responsive and friendly. I loved it here.

This place exceeded our expectations. Good amount of space, well equipped and beautiful surroundings. The driveway leading up to the house was a little tight for a full size SUV but everything else was 10/10.

A stylish peaceful space. An ideal place to relax and unwind for a few days. The house had everything we needed and more and we totally enjoyed our two nights stay. Host was responsive and the whole process was faultless. Thankfully they advised us to download info as cell phone reception is spotty. This came in handy.

This is a nicely secluded 3br spot with everything you'd need for a staycation. The space is laid out well with group hang spaces/furniture and private bedrooms. Fairly well stocked kitchen. They did a nice job of elevating the space without doing renovations. Bathrooms are dated but everything works and it's kinda charming. Master bathroom has a crazy sunken jet tub in the floor.

We had a delightful stay! The house is very well equipped and any questions we had were immediately answered. We had a hard time finding it initially since it was already dark outside. The owner responded right away and gave us clearer directions. Would definitely stay there again.

Lovely stay! It was a great location, clean, nicely decorated and stocked with necessities, and the hosts were responsive. It was hard for us to originally find due to the address coming up differently in Waze, so I suggest using Apple/Googl maps for those who are planning to stay in the future!

Was great! Loved the preserved ‘60s bathrooms!

Peaceful and relax place. Very cozy, felt like home. I would stay again!

Pictures depicted in regards to the patio are not accurate to reality. Water was unsafe to use due to sand residue and yellow tint. Hosts were not communicative in regards to the issue and gave no solution. Had to look for a new place to stay after the first night.