Private Waterfront with Beach-Cabin in Egg Harbor — Guest Reviews

Simple Life Rentals4 bedrooms3 bathsSleeps 10

Review Summary

Overall Rating
4.8 / 5
Total Reviews
6
Sources
Airbnb (3) · Vrbo (3)
Most Recent
Sep 2026

Each review shows: source · star rating · date · guest comments. Reviews are grouped by traveler type. Persona ratings reflect the average score from guests in that category.

All Reviews4.8 avg · 6 reviews
AnthonyVrboSep 2026

Wonderful stay! The property was gorgeous and location was perfect right in the middle between Egg Harbor and Sturgeon Bay. The private lakefront and fire pit were the highlights of the stay.

GuestAirbnbAug 2026

The house is on a Beautiful piece of property. Having the fire pit down by the water is breathtaking. Plenty of room for the whole family. Whoever owns this property, needs to invest in updating. This home isn’t inexpensive to rent, and for the money, it’s lacking quite a bit. Pretty outdated, bedding is bad and not enough furniture on the deck or down by the firepit. The people cleaning should be brushing off the exterior furniture for the next guests.

ElizabethVrboAug 2026

Beautiful water front cabin! It was very clean and comfortable for our family of seven. It was extremely quiet and relaxing, we especially loved the fire pit by the water. This is probably the best house we have rented in our 15 years of going to door county with our kids. I can’t say enough good things about it. We had one small issue which was resolved within ten minutes of us contacting the host. We hope to stay here again soon!

GuestAirbnbJul 2026

Great location. Felt secluded and peaceful.

GuestAirbnbJul 2026

Wonderful time in Door County! This was a great place for our reunion trip, and we loved the porch, the fire pit by the water, and the cozy living room. Heads up, the pathway down to the water is uneven rocks, so will not be accessible if you have mobility issues. We had two toddlers, and they loved playing with the rocks and splashing in the water. This location is close enough to everything, and we especially loved making the trek up to sister bay, and visiting the nearby Rusty Tractor for breakfast.

MeredithVrboJun 2026

We came here for a birthday celebration with my daughter and her friends and it was perfect. The distribution of rooms and beds made it so everyone was comfortable. The house itself is lovely and the location is spectacular. We loved sitting out by the lake watching the sunsets, which were so beautiful that they didn’t even look real. A couple warnings: cell service cuts out a couple miles from the house so make sure you have the door code and wifi password written down before you get there! The wifi in the house works great. And you can’t get delivery out there. We had planned to order pizza our first night and couldn’t! We ended up going to Pizza Bros in Egg Harbor (about 15 mins away) and I’m glad we did because the pizza was fantastic and we had a great time. (Don’t be put off if it looks super busy when you pull up out front, there are a lot more tables inside and out back and they’re very efficient.)Overall it was a great time and a great house and we can’t wait to go back.

Check Availability & Book Direct

View rate calendar · Full listing · Reviews as of Sep 2026