New Construction – Private Lot: Near Sister Bay — Guest Reviews

Simple Life Rentals3 bedrooms2 bathsSleeps 6

Review Summary

Overall Rating
4.6 / 5
Total Reviews
14
Sources
Airbnb (9) · Vrbo (3) · Booking.com (2)
Most Recent
Oct 2026

Each review shows: source · star rating · date · guest comments. Reviews are grouped by traveler type. Persona ratings reflect the average score from guests in that category.

All Reviews4.6 avg · 14 reviews
BillVrboOct 2026

Very accommodating! Loved the place and look forward to staying there in the future!

FrankBooking.comSep 2026

Cozy charming newer home perfectly located. Positive: Very clean and cozy. The location was very convenient to Sister Bay. Negative: The doors were sticky and need adjusting as they made very loud creaks when opening and closing. A few minor additions to the kitchen would be helpful. A large cutting board, a dish rag, towel holders in the bathrooms.

audreyVrboSep 2026

The home is beautiful and with many amenities that made our stay amazing! It is close to many different areas making it a great, central location! Would definitely stay here again.

AmyVrboAug 2026

Incredible. New, nice, quiet and remote. Great space for my team to work out of.

GuestAirbnbAug 2026

Our stay was nice. We loved the location and how quick and easy it was to get places. We loved the outdoor patio and furniture was cozy.

LoriBooking.comJul 2026

A nice spot to relax, well equipped, felt like a private home Positive: Spacious, good location for family trip, we had two 55 YO parents and three 20-something adult children

GuestAirbnbNov 2025

We had an absolutely wonderful weekend and got to stay in a beautiful place. Thank you

GuestAirbnbOct 2025

We overall enjoyed our stay at this airbnb strictly for the location to downtown Sister bay for fall fest, and the space for our group. However, there was some negatives that were not what we expected for paying as much as we did. When we arrived, the code they gave us was incorrect. Thankfully they did respond within 2-5 minutes so it was not a huge hiccup. Our biggest complaints were that the property was not clean. There were multiple cobwebs on baseboards, there were many spiders and flies, ant traps and we found a centipede crawling across the kitchen floor!! Super gross! The beds were average comfort and it was quite hot upstairs without the ability to turn on AC. Lastly, the furniture was very cheap. The dining table was not big enough for us all to sit with 6 plates, the barstools were super small and uncomfortable, the couches were very stiff and uncomfortable and the "mini pool table" was the size of my lab-top. The property was built nicely but the finishes were VERY cheap.

GuestAirbnbAug 2025

New house in a great location with very clear check-in/out instructions. A few reasons for the 3-star review: - Only drips would come out of the faucet/shower head in the upstairs bathroom, and then the shower stopped working completely (the shower lever wouldn’t stay in the “on” position) - The water would occasionally turn rusty-colored, which ended up staining the toilets by the end of our stay - Minimal towels - Very little hand soap in the kitchen/both bathrooms When I reached out to the host via AirBnB, they never responded (even now). Good thing we didn’t have major issues! Overall, an okay experience but we probably wouldn’t stay again unless the issues were fixed and host communication was improved.

GuestAirbnbAug 2025

Great location, central to all the things we wanted to do without the tourist traffic. Home has a beautiful modern aesthetic and is located on a very private, quiet lot. Plenty of space for a family of 4 to spread out. The kids enjoyed the vintage NES and the darts/corn hole games in the garage.

GuestAirbnbAug 2025

Great house and property in a private nature-filled area less than 5 minutes from downtown Sister Bay. House is spacious and clean with modern fixtures. The host was very communicative and responsive, and check in / check out instructions were clear and easy to follow. Would recommend for any group staying in Door County.

GuestAirbnbJul 2025

Such a great find!

GuestAirbnbJun 2025

This is a beautiful house in a very private location, yet just a couple minutes to downtown Sister Bay. The only reason I did not give it a 5 star rating is that it just needs an overall deep cleaning. I shared specific details with the management company and they were very appreciative and responsive. If the items that I mentioned are addressed for the next guests, it will most certainly be a 5 star stay for them. We will definitely plan to stay here again!

GuestAirbnbJun 2025

Spacious home, like new, and great location.

Check Availability & Book Direct

View rate calendar · Full listing · Reviews as of Oct 2026