Each review shows: source · star rating · date · guest comments. Reviews are grouped by traveler type. Persona ratings reflect the average score from guests in that category.
We stayed here for our family’s Christmas and had a wonderful time. \n\nReally lovely property, gorgeous surroundings and such a nice touch to arrive with the place decorated for Christmas, including a tree. Beds were really comfy and the log burning fire added to the cosy feel. Garden was perfect for all our dogs with proper fencing. Kitchen was really well kitted out and the owners gave us great instructions for the Aga, which really helped with cooking a full Christmas dinner! \n\nIt really felt like a proper home away from home to celebrate together. \n\nThanks so much!
GuestAirbnbNov 2025
This house had a lot of character and had everything we needed for our weekend stay. It had nice touches, such as the dog treats and ciders left for us. Great sized bedrooms with comfortable beds. Lovely garden with great views and secure for dogs.
However unfortunately we felt it needed some ‘love’, with a lot of aspects being quite run down, such as the rusting dishwasher door and the rotting gate. The house also did not feel particularly clean, as there was a lot of hair, dust and cobwebs.
We did also feel the house had a number of ‘rules’ which we respected however felt it was hard to keep track.
The location provided was 10 minutes away from the actual house, and whilst the host did provide written instructions, I was unable to follow as I was driving. This was frustrating as we had booked a food delivery to the incorrect address.
Unfortunately due to these reasons we would probably not visit again, which is a shame as it has great potential
GuestAirbnbSep 2025
Stunning location, beautiful property and a wonderful stay. The owners instructions to find the place were spot on, we had used the Airbnb map directions which took us to a place in the village a couple of miles away. Once we stopped and read the owners directions we were ok, a suggestion maybe to pin drop the location and message guests . The barn is beautiful, perfectly spaced for us, 3 couples, my wife and I and our daughters with partners and one dog. Nice touch with a baked cake and some ciders. Plenty of kitchen equipment , kitchen is perfect and the Aga provides ample heat . Sitting room with log burner , log burner and huge sofas allowed for hours of games and laughter. Jenga never fails. Comfortable sleeping arrangements and the joy of ‘ countryside silence’ great walks within 20 minute drive.
GuestAirbnbAug 2024
Overall enjoyed our stay! Quite a few rules for dogs and check out. No toiletries provided which would have been nice
GuestAirbnbJun 2024
We were initially put off by a previous review claiming cameras in the house. Thankfully we decided to go anyway. The cameras were not hidden and were documented in the Welcome Pack. We were told to turn them or remove them, but to put them back in situ when leaving. They are purely for security when no guests are there.
We've travelled! We have never been to a home so beautiful, so private and so comfortable in such breathtaking surroundings. That view was amazing. The beds and the pillows were next level comfortable.
It's always a worry when properties claim the garden is fully fenced.. This garden was fully fenced with sheep fencing too, so I never had to worry that my dog would get out. She's an important part of my life so to see her happy and enjoy being there, made it the perfect place to stay. We will definitely return.
GuestAirbnbJun 2024
The house wasn’t ready to be occupied it looked lined someone popped out to shops
House dirty
Unfinished
No en suite
Smells of dogs
Dirty bins
Dirty accessories
Dirty en suite
Feezrr full of old food
Fridge got old food
No towels
Bed unmade
Bin full of nappies
GuestAirbnbAug 2022
Lovely holiday home, we would definitely return if ever going to that area. Great for the dogs they loved the garden.
Didn’t realise when I booked that I’d be going through Host & Stay’s, responses from them was not always prompt and I do prefer dealing direct with the home owners. Luckily once we’d checked in there were details there in the visitor book for the home owner (couldn’t find back door key to let dogs out and Host & Stays were not able to help luckily home owner was prompt in replying)
Overall a lovely peaceful stay lovely comfy beds and linen very rested couple of days.
GuestAirbnbApr 2022
Beautiful cottage in an amazing location! Extremely comfy bedrooms and lovely to have 3 bathrooms. Very dog friendly too as the garden is completely enclosed. We had a wonderful stay, thank you!
Friend Groups & Gatherings5.0 avg · 7 reviews
GuestAirbnbJan 2026
Spent a lovely 3 days with friends over the new year. The house was as advertised, cosy, comfortable, welcoming. The information from the host was thorough, excellent directions, checking in and out details straight forward, lots of local information provided and more offered if required. All the bedrooms were spacious and had bathrooms, the ground floor room wasn't en suite but it did mean each couple had their own. There was plenty of crockery and cutlery, the aga was lovely and warm but if you chicken out there is a kettle and toaster. \n\nThe house was quite remote, as we expected, so don't expect to be walking down to the pub in the evening. We tended to go out for the day and come back and enjoy the house in the evenings. We had a wander round Monmouth one day and Symonds Yat the second day. Lots of options for pub lunches and dog walks.
GuestAirbnbDec 2025
We stayed here with a group of friends as a pre-Christmas break. A fantastic property in a beautiful setting, we really had a wonderful time. Cannot recommend this property enough!
GuestAirbnbOct 2025
Perfect location for a peaceful weekend away with friends!
GuestAirbnbSep 2025
We had a comfortable stay catching up with friends
GuestAirbnbJan 2025
We loved our stay at Tregaer Mill Barn. It really is a beautiful place, exactly as described. The surrounding area is gorgeous, perfect for walking. Raglan is only a short drive away, ideal for provisions.
The house itself was perfect for us, we were there to celebrate New Year with two other couples. The kitchen / dining room is large and ideal for our meal times and the lounge was perfect for evenings chatting by the fire. Very social.
There are three great size bedrooms, two upstairs with en-suite and one downstairs with a bathroom literally next door.
We had a wonderful time and loved it there. We would definitely recommend this place and would love to revisit.
GuestAirbnbAug 2023
Lovely short break with friends, beautiful scenery, comfy accommodation and competitive price.
SusanVrboJan 2022
Birthday Celebrations
Get together for friends special birhday. The poperty was just what we wanted, spacious, well equipped, warm and cozy. Lovely welcome basket for our arrival. Cant wait to return
Families with Children4.7 avg · 3 reviews
GuestAirbnbAug 2025
Lovely stay with the family. Very tranquil and our dog loved it. Would definitely recommend.
AlisonBooking.comJul 2025
Great place for family get together.
Positive: Very well stocked, especially in the kitchen. Good size bedrooms, nicely furnished. Beautiful views. Good outdoor space. Plenty of information from the hosts.
Negative: Could do with a bit more TLC, inside and out. There were cups et cetera in the kitchen that we had to clean again and there were lots of long established cobwebs . We went in the summer and the Aga has to stay on in the kitchen so it makes that room very hot. Be aware that is not near any facilities so you will have to drive. We knew this and it wasn’t a problem for us. No Internet in the downstairs bedroom. These are small things as in general we were very pleased, but a bit more attention would give this an exceptional score.
GuestAirbnbJun 2025
This house exceeded our expectations in every way- the outside area is beautiful and looks out over fields and hills at the back, also enclosed so was safe for the children to explore, all the rooms were beautiful and our bed was so comfy! The garden faces west so a lovely place to sit and watch the sun set. We wished we could have stayed longer. Thanks very much, we hope to be back!
Nature Lovers4.7 avg · 3 reviews
GuestAirbnbAug 2025
Beautiful cottage right in the middle of the countryside. Great views of the surrounding landscape. Really secluded and peaceful.
We enjoyed sitting out in the garden til dark watching the sunset over the fields and hills.
The house was spotless, and well appointed with everything you’d need.
Host was communicative and friendly
Thoroughly recommended
GuestAirbnbJan 2024
We loved staying at the Barn. The location is very remote (no properties nearby) and the views are stunning overlooking roaming hills.
The house is well appointed. It was lovely and warm when we arrived (was 4C outside and snowing). I personally loved the Aga, as we have a wood fired Rayburn at home.
The living area was very comfortable and stylish while also having a traditional feel.
The three bedrooms are very large and comfortable.
We would stay again
LisaBooking.comNov 2022
Very enjoyable stay, fabulous walks in the Wye Valley
Positive: Cottage was lovely and cosy with the Aga and wood burner. all three bedrooms had large beds with great bed linen. Views from the windows were fab.
Negative: No one's fault but the cottage was remote with narrow winding roads - just be prepared for that. Due to location of cottage and potential problems with taxis we decided to stay in on both evenings.
Holiday Gatherers5.0 avg · 1 review
GuestAirbnbDec 2025
Stayed with family and it was just what we needed. House had been decorated for Christmas, the lady owner called us to make sure all was ok. House feels very homely and is in a beautiful location. What 3 words might be useful as a back up for directions.
We found the barn to be clean, the beds were comfortable. Slow drainage in downstairs shower but easily sortable.
Clear instructions on how to work and use things. Would definitely stay here again!
Hikers & Trail Enthusiasts4.0 avg · 1 review
GuestAirbnbMay 2024
The location and house are beautiful. There is lots to do in the area (hikes, walks, biking), and restaurants/supermarkets are only 10-15 min drive away. The property is not the easiest to find - best to check with the host for the correct location by phone well in advance of arriving there.
Families with Young Children4.0 avg · 1 review
GuestAirbnbJun 2023
Nice to be in a ‘ lived in ‘ house . Very quaint barn conversion and comfy rooms .
The post code on.
the airbnb website does not relate to the property at all and this needs to be addressed asap as the property is several miles away and not easy to find .
The ‘ agas’ are great to cook on if you are used to that method of cooking, otherwise can be difficult, also warm the bedroom above significantly in the summer..
Our daughter mentioned that the rug in the lounge could do with a clean as our 8 month grandson gathered hairs when on the rug .
Overall however, a nice property with a lot of character .
All Reviews4.5 avg · 47 reviews
GuestAirbnbOct 2026
A beautiful house, perfect for our family group. Stunning location.
GuestAirbnbSep 2026
This property is absolutely beautiful, and set in such a peaceful location. The beds were comfortable, and clean. The kitchen was well equipped for what you’d need. The only issue we had was the hot water. As we had a baby with us, the lack of hot water really affected our stay. The host did come back to us promptly when we messaged about the issues, however it wasn’t a quick system. This was the only fault with the property.
GuestAirbnbAug 2026
Absolutely amazing location. It was peaceful, beautiful scenery, fast internet if you need it. I think we spent more time outside and when it got dark we went inside to play the amble amount of board games available. Beautiful place, real cosy and comfortable place.
GuestAirbnbAug 2026
Beautiful place beautiful location
GuestAirbnbJul 2026
Address on Airbnb website not correct. We wondered all around country lanes until we asked a guy in his garden. Told people in two days before us but cobwebs everywhere. Hundred and thousands on coffee table. Needed a thorough proper clean
AsafBooking.comJul 2026
GuestAirbnbJun 2026
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Great Stay "We had a lovely stay at this Airbnb. The property was clean, comfortable, and matched the description. The host was friendly, responsive, and provided clear instructions for check-in and check-out. The location was convenient and made for an enjoyable trip. We would happily stay here again and recommend it to others."
NikkiBooking.comMay 2026
Wonderful and relaxing, home from home.
Positive: Great views, clean and very comfy, had everything we needed and more, clean, and quiet.
Loved the cake on arrival.
Good instructions to find it.
Negative: Nothing to say.
GuestAirbnbMay 2026
We had such a great stay at Tregaer Mill Barn. The property is full of character and charm. The beds are extremely comfortable with beautiful linen. It was great that each room had its own bathroom. Only issue we had was that the Aga was off when we arrived, which took time to get up and running. We contacted the host about it who was responsive and helpful. We would love to stay again!
GuestAirbnbApr 2026
Beautiful house in a beautiful location! Perfect for a get away with friends and the house had everything we needed. Very cosy, clean and comfortable! Lovely garden with great views, very peaceful! Would love to stay again!
RebeccaBooking.comApr 2026
GuestAirbnbMar 2026
Great Venue - really enjoyed.
GuestAirbnbMar 2026
It was beautiful. We had the most amazing, chill weekend and hope to return. There was a lemon drizzle cake there for us which was a lovely touch :)
GrantBooking.comJan 2026
GuestAirbnbDec 2025
Perfect stay, lovely cottage surrounded by beautiful landscape. Was very nice to escape to the countryside for a relaxing weekend.
GuestAirbnbAug 2025
N/A
GuestAirbnbAug 2025
We had a beautiful stay at the barn. A weekend definitely wasn’t long enough! Really lovely touch with the homemade Victoria sponge cake in the fridge too! Beds were incredibly comfortable!
GuestAirbnbAug 2025
Great house, everything you need!
MaryBooking.comJun 2025
Charming house in a secluded location
Positive: Very nice well furnished house and very nice features to the barn, plenty of space and very comfortable.
Lovely views of the area
Nice big dining area and also seating outside to enjoy the weather/garden
Negative: No shampoo or conditioner in bathrooms. Didn't seem to be very well cleaned the fridge was dirty when we arrived but we manage to wipe it down easily but should have been checked by cleaners really.
Quite a lot of rules to be adhered to with cleaning the morning of check out which I felt should be included in the price (stripping beds, emptying dishwasher which felt unrealistic with a 10am checkout)
Checkout would be better at 11am otherwise it feels a rush to get all the cleaning done. Windows has not been cleaned in ages they were dusty and full of cobwebs which spoilt our view from the bedroom
None of these were a huge problem but could have seen some improvements
GuestAirbnbApr 2025
Really enjoyed our stay and was happy with everything will definitely be staying again
KevinVrboJan 2025
Perfect home in a beautiful location
Such a comfortable, cosy and homely property to stay in. Location is also beautiful and everything worked perfectly. Would highly recommend for a relaxing country escape.
WendyBooking.comNov 2024
A lovely place to relax
Positive: Very clean, a lovely welcome pack, plenty of space and a quiet area, AGA warming the kitchen, very good facilities
Negative: N/A
GuestAirbnbAug 2024
Lovely peaceful location.
But not worth the high price tag.
GuestAirbnbJul 2024
Lovely place
GuestAirbnbApr 2024
Lovely place. Beautiful converted barn, well off the beaten track. Spacious, clean, comfy and cosy. Views were stunning.
Would be 5*, except:
1. Address was patently wrong - the Google Maps pin sent on the day directed us to a house a mile down the road. Without signal and on a rainy day, it was a pain trying to find the barn
2. Cameras in the living room. I understand the want to keep an eye on things, but if I'm being surveilled I'd at least like to be told in advance.
GuestAirbnbMar 2024
wonderful location and property . rolling hills and very cosy . the owner couldn't have been more helpful !
GuestAirbnbNov 2023
great house, really comfortable and cozy. the only problem we had was the water pressure quite low so could only use on shower at a time
SusanBooking.comOct 2023
GuestAirbnbSep 2023
Tregaer Mill Barn is a lovely house in a beautiful setting. The sitting room is spacious and comfortable. Everything was spotless. The views are delightful, especially from the downstairs double bedroom and the garden is a lovely, quiet space in which to sit and enjoy the views. It's within striking distance of local sites and activities. The aga made the house a little too hot in a heatwave, which was the only downside.
GuestAirbnbAug 2023
Enjoyed our stay :) would stay again
GuestAirbnbJul 2023
Really nice home in the heart of the welsh countryside. Property was very clean with good facilities it felt more like a home than a rental. The property is quite far away from anywhere and a little tricky to find but great for a rural retreat.
StephenBooking.comMay 2023
HelenBooking.comMay 2023
Regardless of the inconveniences mentioned above, we enjoyed our stay very much.
Positive: The property was clean and attractive and generally well appointed.
Negative: The sofas in the sitting room were very, very uncomfortable. We found it impossible to spend time in the sitting room because of the sofas.
A major problem that visitors coming from overseas experience is the lack of drying facilities in properties. We need to wash our clothes, but we also need to dry them.
GuestAirbnbMar 2023
We had real trouble at this property I'm afraid which was a shame. No heating or hot water for the whole time (sat in coats/hats, beds so cold they felt wet), we left early. I appreciate the effort made by the property owner but unfortunately it just wasn't enough - electric heaters would have been good as an absolute minimum. It's in a nice location and is spacious but seems to be managed at arm's length so the little things that would otherwise be noticed weren't (host manual poor, the welcome gift was a pack of out of date crisps and soft drink, dirty towels but not all were checked because of a short stay).
Initial partial (yet fair) refund request was instantly rejected without explanation or alternative way to compensate, I imagine this was agreed between the host and their agent. Kheem from Airbnb however has been very helpful in granting a part refund and is a delight to deal with.
The property, its size and environment would be worth the money if it had met expectations.
PeterVrboFeb 2023
A lovely location and lovely property.
This is our second time staying at this property and on both occasions it's been lovely.
AshleyBooking.comFeb 2023
Positive: The property is in a lovely location for a break in the country side. Lots of lovely things nearby to do and explore! The beds were comfortable and nice linen. The property is lovely and spacious.
Negative: The property felt a little sad and unkept. There were some issues with the dishwasher where the door is broken (but still useable - just), we found the kettle was full of gunk, one of the casserole pans in the cupboard had mould growing in it. There was a smell of dog throughout the place. The sofas aren't as pictured. This left us feeling like the place was in need of more attention in terms of maintenance and a good deep clean.
GuestAirbnbOct 2022
Very good place, very clean & good facilities while maintaining a good character. Easy check in & check out. Nice cosy bedrooms with very good living room space. Finding the place may be difficult just follow the step by step instructions in the guide book. Host & Stay can make this a bit more clearer in their communication.
GuestAirbnbOct 2022
We loved our stay. The beautiful stone mill house was wonderfully cosy and quiet with a pretty garden and lovely outlook over the rolling hills. Country kitchen with a warming Aga.
Modern amenities and soft comfy beds
Highly recommended, thanks so much.
Would definitely visit again.
GuestAirbnbSep 2022
Great cottage- will definitely be back!
GuestAirbnbSep 2022
The actual property was nice, however some aspects were completely unacceptable. There was no hot water for the first day of the stay and communication with the host was limited and dismissive despite this being a necessity in an air bnb. We felt that the host did not care about this.
SusanBooking.comAug 2022
relaxing visit, in a lovely part of Wales. cottage was charming and very comfortable
Positive: beautifully spacious cottage, in a lovely surrounding, with all amenities
GuestAirbnbJul 2022
Great cottages for a relaxing stay. Went we 3 couples and 3 dogs and there was plenty of space in the garden to play and all fences were secure. Perfect base for local walks
GuestAirbnbMay 2022
Fabulous stay, hope to return soon!
GuestAirbnbMar 2022
Great stay at Tregaer Mill Barn. A very homely property, great for a family weekend, in a lovely part of the country with stunning views across the countryside. Only negative: the listing states that all three bedrooms have king size or double beds, whereas one of the rooms on the first floor actually has two singles.
GuestAirbnbMar 2022
We had a rocky start with the property due to unforseen issues with the boiler, but the log burner and aga kept the property extremely cosey downstairs. Our hosts worked tirelessly to rectify any and all issues, and were on hand at all times to answer any questions.
The way the issues were handled swiftly tells a lot about the care the hosts have for their guests, and these issues were no fault of theirs... Just bad luck. Their hardwork and dedication to making my stay as comfortable as can be is reflected in my review.
Great scenery and off the grid location, beautiful accommodation, cider and snacks layed out on arrival, and comfy beds for the best sleep Iv had in ages.
Highly recommend.
GuestAirbnbJan 2022
What a fantastic cottage, which was larger than we were expecting. It has all home comforts and the wood burner was a real bonus during the winter evenings. Each bedroom had use of its own bathroom, which was perfect for the five adults. I would highly recommend this cottage and will definitely book again if returning to the area.
GuestAirbnbDec 2021
Lovely peaceful location well equipped. Loved the Arga