Each review shows: source · star rating · date · guest comments. Reviews are grouped by traveler type. Persona ratings reflect the average score from guests in that category.
Lovely stay at the Beacon in Goathland.
The lodge is decorated, furnished to a high standard.
The beds are very comfortable. The water is hot.
The only thing that was missing for me personally is a bath robe/dressing gown.
The area is stunning!
Great for walking, or visiting nearby Whitby/Staithes etc.
We will definitely go back in warmer weather as we missed the steam train.
Thank you for the lovely stay, clear directions and easy straightforward check in/out.
GuestAirbnbNov 2025
We did have a few minor issues when we first arrived, but they did not detract from our stay at this lovely cottage. So on the negative side, no heating or hot water on arrival due to a boiler fault. The microwave and some crockery had been left dirty by a previous guest.
On the plus side the cottage is beautifully decorated and very comfortably furnished. Its in the perfect location with views of open moorland from the bedroom windows, and walks straight from the door. Its a few minutes walk into the village centre and 10 minutes to the steam railway. We wouldn't hesitate to book this cottage again.
GuestAirbnbOct 2025
We really enjoyed our stay at The Lodge. It was cosy and perfectly equipped for our stay. Peaceful setting with wonderful walks and tearooms close by. Thank you!
GuestAirbnbOct 2025
Beautiful place to spend a few days exploring the Dales. Great location, very peaceful.
GuestAirbnbSep 2025
We visit Goathland multiple times per year, and this is one of the nicest places we’ve stayed. Pubs all in walking distance, cafe, bus stop across the road. Great walks on the doorstep. Amazing views, and a gorgeous cottage. We didn’t want to leave. All the rooms were decorated beautifully, modern, but a cottage feel. Had everything we needed. We’d definitely stay again. Highly recommend. Oh, beds were so comfortable too.
GuestAirbnbApr 2025
If you are looking for a base whilst visiting Goathland or the surrounding areas this property is perfect! The views from both bedrooms are stunning.
There is everything you need in the property and the location is just across the road to start the walk to Mallyan Sprout Waterfall and it’s a 15 minute walk (max) to the train station.
GuestAirbnbMar 2025
The lodge is beautifully decorated and furnished, comfy bed, great deep free standing bath. Moorland walks 2 mins away. Great pub meal at the mallyan spout 2 mins across the road. Lots of amenities provided in the lodge. Goathland village is a 15 min walk away. Ample private parking. However as we were the 1st guests to stay in the lodge there was a few minor negatives. The blue sofa is not very comfy. A blind / curtain is needed on the entrance door for privacy on an evening. A larger mirror is needed in the bedroom. Otherwise we had a brilliant stay.
Families with Children5.0 avg · 3 reviews
GuestAirbnbFeb 2026
Great location, clean inside and nice facilities inside. Great for a small family, we would definitely stay again.
GuestAirbnbOct 2025
Lovely place looks exactly like the photos. Gorgeous inside felt like 5 star. Very clean, all that let it down as the kitchen appliances I.e pans weren’t very clean so probably just need a check when it’s cleaned as can’t rely on previous guests to clean them well! Otherwise spotless and gorgeous throughout.
Bed very comfy.
WiFi did keep dropping at night which was an issue as we have an owlet sock monitoring our baby and it didn’t work , also couldn’t watch TV. It was windy one night but wasn’t the best service throughout. However Goathland is a no signal zone which we appreciate.
Perfect location for exploring the moors and enjoying the railway.
5 stars would stay again
GuestAirbnbAug 2025
We loved our stay at the lodge. Beautiful peaceful location - our little boy loved waking up to the sheep at his window! Great base for exploring the areas
Pet Owners4.5 avg · 2 reviews
GuestAirbnbNov 2025
Very comfy and ideal with the dogs / for walking the lovely north York moors
GuestAirbnbMar 2025
A great find for my hubby with our Working GSP’s for attending training on the beautiful Grouse Moors within 10 minute drive .
Excellent host and will be back again
Thankyou Dale
Luxury Seekers4.0 avg · 1 review
HelenBooking.comOct 2025
Fabulous location and beautiful residence. The quality of the fixtures was very high and confortable the bedrooms were
Positive: Beautiful decor - very high end quality.
Negative: 3 tea bags provided and only 1 tea towel, which didn’t appear clean. A small welcome pack including a little fresh milk would have been appreciated. I know it’s self catering but for such lovely accommodation, I think this would go a long way with visitors.
Outdoor & Adventure Seekers4.0 avg · 1 review
GuestAirbnbSep 2025
We stayed for short break. Dark when we arrived so was a little difficult to find (our fault), but easy access. Lovely interior, comfy beds (slept brilliantly). Lovely, peaceful, scenic area, ideally located for walkers, cyclists, attractions/places to visit.
Accessibility Needs4.0 avg · 1 review
PatVrboJul 2025
A very peaceful break
A truly lovely accommodation and we found it to be spotlessly clean. Very well equipped with light, moder with all high end fixtures and fittings throughout. Gorgeous views from both bedrooms. The TV as mentioned in other reviews is not that straightforward as all we needed was live BBC or ITV, we could only find Iplayer or ITVx, plenty of TV apps though. That said we weren't desperate to watch the TV anyway. We were a party of four adults all in our 70s and had booked just a two night break, we would gladly return but would have preferred a walk in shower as the bath (with overhead and hand held showers) is quite high and deep with no hand rail to help to assist with climbing in and out along with glass screen doors we all felt it was possibly an accident waiting to happen, that was our only negative but had we been staying longer it would have proven to be a very big negative. Great parking, nice to have the outside table and chairs too! We were met on arrival by Ben the owner who just happened to at home next door we were greeted very warmly and told if we needed anything he would be only to happy to help. All in all a great place, sadly not having the walk in shower was our only reason for not returning in the future.
Couples5.0 avg · 1 review
GuestAirbnbJul 2025
Had a great weekend in Goathland with a fab walk. The cottage was the perfect size and location for us (2 couples) for 2 nights - Goathland has 3 pubs and a couple of cafes so is well catered for.
Nice touches were phone chargers in the bedroom and lounge and a smart tv. Kitchen had what we needed (although we didn’t cook) and shower was perfect. Plenty of parking out the front. Everything was clean and tidy and access was easy with clear communication from the host.
Foodies & Culinary Explorers5.0 avg · 1 review
GuestAirbnbJul 2025
A beautifully decorated comfortable and cosy cottage, right in the centre of Goathland. Opposite Homestead Kitchen, which was perfect for our visit.
The bedrooms and space were very comfortable and the kitchen had great facilities.
Our only small bump along the way was that there was no salt or oil left to cook our dinner, so we would recommend taking a small hamper of basics to use in the kitchen.
We would very happily return!
Thanks for having us!
Hikers & Trail Enthusiasts4.0 avg · 1 review
GuestAirbnbApr 2025
We really enjoyed our stay at the lodge. The accommodation is clean, tidy, warm, with comfortable bedrooms and modern facilities.
The kitchen is well stocked. The fixtures and fittings all feel premium. The rooms heat up quickly if you need a heating boost. The surroundings are quiet and it is a great place for walkers to base themselves.
The only thing I would have liked is some outdoor furniture as the outside is a sun trap and a great wind break. We had perfect weather so this little extra would have been most welcome. However, we would stay again and recommend it to others.
All Reviews4.8 avg · 64 reviews
GuestAirbnbOct 2026
Perfect little weekend stay. Lovely peaceful location, in walking distance to pubs/tearooms/shops and rural walks. The cottage was spotlessly clean and had everything we needed. Beautifully decorated and very cosy. The little sheep snoozing outside our bedrooms was a lovely little bonus. Would recommend to anyone and would definitely stay here again. Thank you for a lovely stay. 🩷
GuestAirbnbOct 2026
A wonderful stay with all you needed to relax and enjoy the wonderful surroundings
EmmaBooking.comSep 2026
Lovely stat at great location in a clean and comfortable cottage.
Positive: Second stay at this cottage. Lovely location and is clean and comfortable.
Negative: New enclosed garden which would think is great for dogs except not allowed to do their business on the new gravel and stones so had to still put dog on lead and take out which was an inconvenience late at night. Would have been nice for dog to roam since it’s a dog friendly property.
GuestAirbnbSep 2026
Eight nights at The Beacon and didn’t want to leave. So quiet with the occasional passing sheep saying hello but on the edge of the village so not far from familiar Heartbeat locations. Great to meet the owner briefly who has a house next door.
Both the Goathland “Aidensfield” Arms and the Mallyan Hotel (across the road from The Lodge) have very good bar meals and the cottage has a very well equipped kitchen.
The cottage is modern and comfortable inside with two decent sized bedrooms with moorland views. Plenty of power sockets thoughtfully placed. The bathroom was spotless. The two or four steps up into it depending on where you are coming from might be an issue for some as might stepping into the in bath shower.
Several walks from outside the cottage including the valley where the Mallyan Spout Waterfall decends, the North Yorkshire Moors railway is 20 minutes walk the other side of the village for trips to Pickering and Whitby, or take the 840 bus from across the road.
GuestAirbnbSep 2026
Absolutely loved the little cottage. Will definitely go back and visit again!
GuestAirbnbAug 2026
Lovely stay at the Lodge, Goathland was very picturesque with great walks that are easily accessible from the Lodge.
Accommodation had everything that we needed and loved the new garden.
GuestAirbnbAug 2026
Just came back from a couple of days in goathland and what a lovely time we had. Cottage in a perfect place, just a bit further out from the busy village so you’re nice and peaceful but still close walk in to the village. Private parking, secure garden for little ones. Lovely hosts, checked in with us to make sure everything okay and always quick with responses. Thank you. We look forward to returning.
GuestAirbnbAug 2026
This was the perfect stay for us in Goathland for 4 adults, a baby and a dog. The house was beautifully decorated, especially the brand new garden area. Fantastic value for money and location, we would recommend to anybody visiting the area!
GuestAirbnbJul 2026
This was our second time in Goathland but first time staying at the Lodge and honestly it was perfect. Location is fantastic, within 5 minutes walk from everything but just enough out the way for privacy while at the Lodge.
Very modern inside with everything you would need for your stay.
Definitely recommend, we will be re-booking very soon.
GeorginaBooking.comJul 2026
Fabulous! Perfect accommodation in a beautiful location.
Positive: Everything about The Lodge was fantastic - stunning, peaceful location, yet within a few minutes walk of cafes, pubs and the local shop. The garden area was beautiful and lovely to sit out in the sunshine. Inside, the decor was lovely, beds super comfy, we had everything we needed for a weekend,
Negative: Nothing. We loved everything about it and would highly recommend. Would love to come and stay again!
rebeccaBooking.comJul 2026
GuestAirbnbJul 2026
Great place to stay. Very well equipped and good location.
AllisonVrboJul 2026
Beautiful property in a beautiful location. The lodge is very well equipped and has everything needed for a stress free holiday. It is furnished and decorated to a high standard, with stunning outside space to sit and enjoy a relaxed drink. The host was responsive to messages and instructions were very clear so we had no problems finding the place or checking in/out. We especially loved waking up to the sound of sheep outside the bedroom window and exploring the local area. The recommendations of places to visit were really helpful especially if you’re not familiar with the area. Would highly recommend this property and will definitely be back.
GuestAirbnbJul 2026
we always use host and stay. they have a lot of properties in the areas we like to stay. and they are beautiful. can recommend them , excellent
GuestAirbnbJul 2026
We had a four night stay at The Beacon which we enjoyed very much. Lovely private garden. Doggy friendly and secure. Multitudes of walks straight from the accommodation, not to mention the north York moors railway. Had one minor issue with a blocked drain when we arrived but this was resolved quickly when we reported it and in no way compromised our holiday.
Goathland is a wonderful location, would definitely stay again
NicolaBooking.comJul 2026
GuestAirbnbJul 2026
The accommodation was absolutely perfect for our stay. The house is well positioned with walks from the doorstep, The Mallyan Spout Hotel is opposite, tearooms and the Heritage train is a short walk. The house is decorated and furnished to a high spec. The shower is powerful and the bathroom facilities are high quality. I would highly recommend a stay here. If we come back to the area again we will definitely stay here.
GuestAirbnbJul 2026
A wonderful place to stay in a beautiful location on the edge of the village. Spacious and well laid out. Kitchen fully equipped.
Only a short walk into village with lots of scenic walks in the area.
Loved the quirkiness of the couple of steps into bedroom and bathroom.
Ample parking
CaraBooking.comJun 2026
Beautiful little property, lovely decor and perfect quiet spot in the countryside.
williamBooking.comJun 2026
Perfect Break
Positive: Beautiful lodge, set in a great location. Perfect for the "Heartbeat experience ". Lodge was private, comfortable with everything you need for your stay.
Negative: Nothing to dislike.
TracyBooking.comJun 2026
Positive: Very spacious, really comfortable bed and so clean.
CatherineBooking.comJun 2026
In an amazing location
Positive: A very comfortable and well maintained cottage in an amazing location
Negative: Property was extremely clean and had everything you need for a lovely stay in Goathland
GuestAirbnbMay 2026
Such a lovely little house at the edge of the village, new garden was amazing for sitting out in the evening. Really cosy and well decorated interior. Everything you need for a few nights away!
GuestAirbnbMay 2026
Great place to stay in such a beautiful location. Very quiet and peaceful but also only short walk to the middle of Goathland, as well as some lovely walks. Owner very responsive and helpful. We would definitely visit again.
GuestAirbnbMay 2026
Absolutely fantastic house. Beautifully designed and set out. Felt really at home there. We will be back, got engaged at the waterfalls on the first day staying there. So this house now holds a very special place with me and my other half! Would highly recommend to anyone who enjoys the countryside and walking! Beautiful area to stay! Thank you very much for a lovely week!
GuestAirbnbMay 2026
What a beautiful place to stay - gorgeous decor and extremely private and peaceful. Very well equipped accommodation, they really have thought of everything! We had a brilliant time and wouldn’t hesitate to recommend this lovely house as a base for exploring the area.
GuestAirbnbMay 2026
Wonderful place to stay in beautiful surroundings. Would definitely recommend.
GuestAirbnbApr 2026
A lovely cottage in a beautiful setting. Very clean and spacious for a weekend stay.
The bath is very high to climb into if you are elderly with nothing to grab onto. ( my mum struggled and needed help) a handle to grab onto would be useful.
Stated as dog friendly but lots of rules to adhere to would advise anyone staying to check it's suitable for their dog.
AshleighBooking.comApr 2026
GuestAirbnbApr 2026
The Lodge is a perfect place to stay for a couple, or couple of couples, to explore the coast-side edge of the North Yorkshire moors. Well thought out, clean and cosy with great views of the moors. The newly done garden was lovely to sit out in at sunset too.
Would definitely come back for longer another time :)
GuestAirbnbApr 2026
Lovely place, location couldnt be better, so peacefull.
GuestAirbnbMar 2026
Beautiful little hideaway, lovely, clean and comfortable we will be back
GuestAirbnbFeb 2026
Lovely house in a great setting. We had a snowy weekend but that didn't stop us as the roads were really well cleared. Lovely breakfast in Goathland and a pub just across the road for dinner. Everything as described, comfortable and cosy.
GuestAirbnbJan 2026
Beautiful place in beautiful surroundings. High standard of finish throughout the property and good comfy beds.
GuestAirbnbJan 2026
Was beautiful - Hotel with pub across the road, lovely village shops, tea room, amazing views out of bedroom and living room, the decoration was amazing, lovely body washes, soaps, all the attention to detail - everything you needed in the kitchen to cook meals.. short drive into Whitby - and amazing sunsets!!!!!
GuestAirbnbJan 2026
Top notch accommodation beautifully decorated.
GuestAirbnbDec 2025
The place is very well located, and both bedrooms have a lovely view.
GuestAirbnbDec 2025
Beautiful little cottage in a tranquil location. Unfortunately the property was not very clean- dust and cobwebs were the common theme throughout which was a real shame.
GuestAirbnbDec 2025
Beautiful modern cottage, a little tricky to find in the dark but got there in the end. Lovely location, very peaceful and very comfy beds.
louiseBooking.comDec 2025
Disappointingly dirty
Positive: We loved the location and the beautiful village. The cottage has been decorated to a very high standard and the bed was exceptionally comfortable. Sadly what let's the owner down is the management company host and stay who manage the property and the cleaning.
The day before we were booked to go the village was closed due to the snow and no access possible...it made the national news. The company did kindly contact the owner to ask if we could change the dates if it was still inaccessible but we did manage to get there thanks to having a 4x4. And there sadly the positives end and I fell terrible for the owner having to write all the issues but it is clear that host and stay simply are not interested.
Negative: We stayed for 2 nights and the accomodation was filthy. I spent over an hour cleaning before we could settle in for the weekend. a real disappointment when the cottage is so beautifully decorated by the owner.
I did not ring the company on arrival as has been suggested that I should have done by them so that they could send a cleaner out as I just wanted to get it clean and be able to relax. No cleaner could have arrived at that time and under such short notice to be enable us to try and enjoy the weekend. Plus what kind of employer would put their team at risk travelling to such a location late at night in such terrible weather conditions...snow and ice.
List of issues...
Bathroom
Dirty cloth, dried and musty on the window ledge
Dirty toilet brush
Dirty toilet seat
Shower pipe black
Pubic hair in the bath
Dirty toothbrush holder
Kitchen
Coffee grinds left in cafettiere
Dirty utensil drainer
Dirty drainer
Dirty sink
Dirty worktop near sink
Dirty oven trays
Dirty frying pan
Dirty crockery and cutlery and cups.
Had to wash everything we were going to use
No instructions on how to use oven, dishwasher and washer/dryer
Room
Dirty throw
Hall and 1st bedroom
Dirty rugs .. had to roll up and put to one side they were so filthy
Everywhere ..... Cobwebs.
I hope the owner is able to read this and can arrange for a deep clean andy advice....get a different management company as host and stay are really letting you down.
GuestAirbnbOct 2025
Modern, clean and beautifully decorated cottage in stunning surroundings. Walks in all directions from the front gate and walkable to local pubs and tea shops. We only stayed a couple of nights but could see there being an issue with the lack of food cupboard space in the kitchen for longer stays.
KarenVrboSep 2025
We really enjoyed our stay at The Lodge. The property was modern, clean and well appointed. Any questions we had prior to our visit were answered promptly. We loved the peace and quiet and the location was excellent, a 10 minute walk to a few shops and a bit further to Goathland train station. We would definitely return and would recommend staying here.
GuestAirbnbSep 2025
Beautiful lodge, had everything we needed and in a lovely location! Will absolutly come back and stay!
CatherineBooking.comSep 2025
GuestAirbnbSep 2025
we had slight trouble with the location. when booking the property was called The Lodge, on checking in before leaving home it was called Memorial Cottages and on arrival when we finally found it, it was called The Beacon. all very confusing.
we had a problem with no water one night, and Host and Stay were very helpful in getting a plumber to come out at 11pm to help. he managed to get us cold water and then we had to wait until the next evening for a heating engineer to come and sort out the hot water. all not ideal but at least it was dealt with.
JaneBooking.comAug 2025
Lovely cottage, so peaceful and relaxing
Positive: Very clean, private and quiet. In a lovely village, surrounded by open fields and sheep
Negative: Nothing at all
JodieBooking.comAug 2025
Positive: Location and very cosy property
Negative: No internet/TV first night. Cobwebs in bedroom, and cleaner showed up at 9.30 when check out wasnt until 10. She didn't enter the property but parked outside getting her things out. Which added pressure to vacating the property
karenBooking.comAug 2025
Exceptional location
Positive: Location was beautiful
Opening your bedroom curtains to see sheep looking in ..quite an experience 😄
Negative: Oven fiddly to work out how to use
Very minor issue
EmmaBooking.comAug 2025
Had a lovely stay home from home.
Positive: Lovely decor. Like how it’s one level. Parking in garden. Location is lovely.
Negative: Nothing
KerryBooking.comAug 2025
Positive: Beautiful location and place to stay.
JulieBooking.comJul 2025
Lovely weekend away and we will be back!
Positive: Home from home lovey to chill out in a gorgeous setting
Negative: Nothing
GazBooking.comJul 2025
If I return to Goathland i will happily book again.
Positive: Location is great with a short walk to village/train station. Close to Mallyan spout hotel which had fantastic food if you don’t fancy cooking each night. Decor is great and has been well thought out.
Negative: Steps to bathroom could be an issue at night for some but I think the sensor lights being implemented in the hallway is a great solution.
T.V not the most user friendly, Aerial/sat signal if possible for live channel switching instead of internet/app signing in to watch. Can be an faff/issue for non tech savvy guests. Not a end of the world issue
ChristineBooking.comJul 2025
Lovely weekend getaway
Positive: Lovely location as not far from village centre
, and close to what we wanted to do, very clean and tidy
Negative: No cupboard space to put supplies, had to leave on counter tops, maybe could have used cups and glasses shelf by moving things around, found one sofa a bit uncomfortable and struggled to get tv to do what we wanted, but think that was our issue as we are not the best on technology things.
KarenBooking.comJun 2025
Lovely accommodation in a beautiful location but beware the steps!
Positive: Comfortable, clean, spacious. Goathland is a hidden gem! A surprisingly busy town with some lovely restaurants and cafes and amazing to see the. Sheep grazing everywhere!
Negative: The steps! There are three separate pairs of steps in the property and there is not a way to not have to use them. As soon as we arrived we knew they would be dangerous for night time visits to the bathroom. Sure enough, night 2 half asleep going to the bathroom I went flying down the steps landing hard on my knees and hitting my head. Definitely was concussed. Thankfully ok now but beware of this if you book here.
GuestAirbnbJun 2025
The perfect stay in a great location. Pubs and beautiful walks right on your doorstep. The decor was lovely and it was clean and tidy. Would definitely recommend a stay if you are looking for a wholesome little trip away.
LubaBooking.comJun 2025
Lovely peaceful retreat
Positive: The accommodation was in a peaceful location on the edge of the village. It was very clean and the beds were very comfortable. The decor was beautiful and modern.
Negative: There was no telephone signal at the accomodation so all communications were on WiFi. One of the bedrooms was quite dark so great for sleep but difficult to do other things.
GuestAirbnbJun 2025
We had a lovely, relaxing stay at The Beacon in Goathland. It was easy to find and access. The place was well furnished and had everything we needed.
SarahBooking.comMay 2025
Fantastic, will definitely be booking again
Positive: Beautiful location, lovely and clean
Negative: One minor minor comment would be the wifi details, when you don’t have any phone signal and the details are on the booking info you can’t access it
GuestAirbnbMay 2025
We had a great time at the Lodge.
This is an excellent place to stay and is ideally situated to enjoy the coast and surrounding countryside.
The accommodation is to a very high standard and is well equipped.
The courtyard is sheltered and a good place to soak up the sun with a table and chairs.
We would thoroughly recommend the Lodge and look forward to returning for another holiday.
Anthony
GuestAirbnbMay 2025
Beautiful place, excellent position, lots of walks from the property. Private and very quiet.
ChristopherBooking.comMay 2025
GRAHAMBooking.comMay 2025
quiet, cosy and comfortable.
Positive: such a cosy little home. beautifully decorated and furnished, with everything we needed for a very comfortable stay. we are going back in June so that says it all really. a pleasant walk into Goathland, not too far but there are car parks in the village if youre not wanting to walk or if youve a train to catch at the fabulous station. views from the property very nice too.
Negative: n/a
GuestAirbnbMay 2025
Fabulous place and superb location. We’ll definitely look to book again. Great communication as well.
GuestAirbnbMay 2025
Great location for a few days walking. Very cosy and comfortable property with all amenities required. Local pubs are very welcoming and of a high standard