Each review shows: source · star rating · date · guest comments. Reviews are grouped by traveler type. Persona ratings reflect the average score from guests in that category.
A lovely place for peacefully relaxing by the fireplace. The surrounding woods were great for walking thru the snow with my dogs. The inside was homey and well decorated to give you that feeling of old-fashioned comfort. We greatly appreciate the peaceful vibes the home gave off.
Our snowy Thanksgiving stay at the Red Cottage property was magical. The house was beautiful, extremely clean, comfortable, well stocked, and airy, with plenty of windows to let in outside light and provide 360 degree views of the property and its landscape. The hosts were very responsive to questions and concerns. The house was easy to find, close Livingston Manor and its shopping and dining opportunities, and provided easy access to other local attractions. The whole stay deserves an enthusiastic five star rating! Both we and our son and his wife would definitely consider staying here again in the future.
10/10 we didn’t want to leave . Such a BEAUTIFUL PEACEFUL PLACE !!! Love the pro at absolutely love the outdoor amenities the hot tub 10/10 the indoor decorations and furniture personally I loved !! I love a clean place and this was perfect for me and my family. Kitchen well equipped ! Bedroom omg loved . Definitely coming back !
My son and I had a great stay and can't wait to return.
Outstandingly beautiful! Surrounded by trees and wildlife. Very clean and management was extremely helpful and responsive.
They were very responsive and the home was beautiful. We enjoyed all the amenities and everything was very comfortable. There were some challenges with the fire place and they helped us out right away and made sure to take care of things. Would stay again.
View rate calendar · Full listing · Reviews as of Jul 2026