Loved this place! Would stay again! Positive: Loved the old house, but liked the upgrades. And the location was awesome! Negative: The only thing I could suggest, was the fridge didn’t keep things very cold, but the freezer worked great.
Each review shows: source · star rating · date · guest comments. Reviews are grouped by traveler type. Persona ratings reflect the average score from guests in that category.
Loved this place! Would stay again! Positive: Loved the old house, but liked the upgrades. And the location was awesome! Negative: The only thing I could suggest, was the fridge didn’t keep things very cold, but the freezer worked great.
My stay at this home was great! It's a 15 minute walk from the main part of Sturgeon Bay, which was great for a Sunday on the town. Everything was clean and worked as expected.
We had a wonderful time staying in Sturgeon Bay for our vacation. We walked to breakfast at Morning Glory and walked through the farmers market afterwards on Saturday. We also walked to Kitty O’Reillys for some drinks and live music. We were able to have a couple bonfires and grilled out 2 of our dinners. Dinning table was perfect for meals and games! We took day trips to Washington Island, Egg Harbor, Sisters Bay (goats on the roof), and Fish Creek (boat tour). Amazing time and the perfect place to stay!!!
It’s a good stay. Thank you
Overall, was a great place to stay. Very walkable to local restaurants and the water. Fairly close to the other tourist areas such as Egg Harbor, Fish Creek, and Sister Bay. We loved how quiet it was as well. Host was very responsive for any issues that came up.
This is an adequate place to stay, a little rough but possibly better than the pictures allow. The curtain on the bedroom is not as problematic as I would've thought. The location is great, super close to Kitty's Irish Pub. The A/C works great (it got up to 90 with 95% humidity while we were here). There aren't many plugs. The porch was too filthy to sit on. But the price was right.
Such a wonderful getaway! The apartment was quaint, cozy, and had everything we needed for a relaxing stay. It was the perfect home base for touring the neighboring bays, and we loved coming back after a day of exploring. Great location, peaceful atmosphere, and a charming touch throughout. Would absolutely stay here again!
While everything appeared very clean, we were overwhelmed with a strong smoke/nicotine odor upon walking inside. We messaged the host who was helpful and responsive, but my husband thought chemical freshener would just add to his headache so we had to open windows for a few hours and run a fan. It was pretty frustrating after reading and expecting this to be a smoke free rental. We also traveled with our baby and was expecting the noise after 10pm to be taken seriously by the upstairs unit who were up having a party literally all night. Also, should note that the bathroom door hits the counter as it closes and when you shower the wood swells so it takes a lot of force to pull open the door, a child would not be strong enough and would get stuck. This was a fantastic location and host, my issues are primarily other people (smell and noise), I'd still highly recommend if looking for a clean walkable place.
The house had a lot of charming character inside and out and the host was very communicative. We really enjoyed our time there and it made for a great home base for a weekend getaway.
View rate calendar · Full listing · Reviews as of Oct 2026