Downtown Sister Bay - 2022 New Construction home — Guest Reviews

Simple Life Rentals4 bedrooms3.5 bathsSleeps 12

Review Summary

Overall Rating
4.9 / 5
Total Reviews
12
Sources
Airbnb (7) · Vrbo (5)
Most Recent
Oct 2026

Each review shows: source · star rating · date · guest comments. Reviews are grouped by traveler type. Persona ratings reflect the average score from guests in that category.

All Reviews4.9 avg · 12 reviews
JedVrboOct 2026

Great property. Great location. It comfortably fit 10 people.

GuestAirbnbSep 2026

Everything was great, thank you!

LauraVrboAug 2026

We had a really nice time. The property was very clean , the bedrooms were extremely comfortable, and it was well stocked with cookware and the like . It’s advertised as a 4 bedroom but it definitely has 5, so we paid for more than what we needed. The basement was very cold which we were pre- warned by another review and used blankets and it was great for sleeping, but too cold during the day. We really wish it had a fire pit as we enjoyed sitting outside at night. Other than that it was great!

JasonVrboJul 2026

shower curtain liner needs to be changed mildew with musty smell. basement extremely cold, we did appreciate the extra blankets. Everything else was very nice.

GuestAirbnbJul 2026

Great house, well located. I exactly as advertised. Great for a large group too. Would definitely stay here again

GuestAirbnbOct 2025

Fantastic rental all around!

GuestAirbnbSep 2025

It was great!

GuestAirbnbSep 2025

Beautiful home, very clean, very walkable to the downtown area. Would definitely stay here again. The listing says 7 cars can park there but only 4 cars were allowed to park there, which was a little less than ideal, but we were able to park cars at a lot downtown near the marina with their guidance.

GuestAirbnbAug 2025

It was amazing. The only thing I didn't enjoy was the parking situation. I understand Sister Bay has rules but it became a problem at times.

GuestAirbnbJul 2025

This is a clean, well equipped, new, conveniently located home. Our large group had space to spread out and enjoy time together. It was easy to stay in and cook with the well stocked kitchen. Plenty of extra towels and blankets for all. Thank you for a wonderful gathering place!

JeanVrboSep 2024

Sisters Weekend Six of us sisters spent the weekend in Door County. We chose this home because it was new and clean and tastefully decorated. It was a very comfortable home and plenty of room for the six of us. There was a lovely patio with a fire pit table and chairs that made the stay even better. If we ever come back to Door County we would definitely stay there again.

SarahVrboSep 2024

Exactly What We Were Looking For The home was clean, comfortable, and a great home base for daily adventures.

Check Availability & Book Direct

View rate calendar · Full listing · Reviews as of Oct 2026