Downtown Fish Creek, Sleeps 6 - Yellow Birch Cottage — Guest Reviews

Simple Life Rentals2 bedrooms2.5 bathsSleeps 6

Review Summary

Overall Rating
4.5 / 5
Total Reviews
24
Sources
Vrbo (12) · Airbnb (12)
Most Recent
Oct 2026

Each review shows: source · star rating · date · guest comments. Reviews are grouped by traveler type. Persona ratings reflect the average score from guests in that category.

All Reviews4.5 avg · 24 reviews
GuestAirbnbOct 2026

The Airbnb aesthetically was lovely. However a non working television in the main sitting area was very inconvenient. We were gone all day and in order to watch the 6:20pm football game we had to head back out to watch it in a bar. We specifically rented this for the great room to eat dinner and watch the game. We reported the television not working upon check in and spent 30 minutes trying to troubleshoot. Not what someone who spent tons of money wants to spend their time doing on vacation. It was left we will talk with the owners and we never heard back. Lots of out lights in the condo. The fireplace under the television didn’t work and overall I would recommend saving your money and rent another Airbnb.

PattyVrboOct 2026

We never saw that one needed a Roku to watch TV..Very disappointed since I don't have Roku. We were hoping to watch Sunday Night Football, Chicago Bears and could not watch it. Cound not watch Chicago Whites Sox or Cubs either. No TV was available to.us. wish the amenities in the kitchen was newer. Property needs some updates. We won't be going back.Very disappointing. We couldn't watch any other channels as we didn't bring our password with us.Wish wewould have known this ahead of time Expensive especially with no TV and limited kitchen utensils. No toaster either.

LizettVrboSep 2026

Great location (walk to downtown), very clean, lots of storage, nice size kitchen and each bedroom has a full bath with good water pressure. Host was very responsive and attentive. Would stay here again. You could also rent other condos next door if multiple families come. Pool was good for younger kids.

GuestAirbnbJul 2026

Enjoyable weekend overall home very nice space. Only issue is the bed in second bedroom was not comfortable

MichelleVrboJul 2026

We took a mini girl's weekend vacation, we wanted to stay where everything was in walking distance, each have our own bed, 2 showers, shop, relax, good food, clean and comfortable. From the moment we arrived we knew we picked the right spot. the house was clean, spacious and convenient. We enjoyed sitting on the patio relaxing having coffee in the morning, people watching and just talking, it was our go to spot. Shopping and eating were a short walk away, yet we were out of the busy part, so it was not noisy. Bailey's Harbor and Sister Bay were a very short drive away. Saturday, we enjoyed relaxing in the swimming pool for a few hours to get out of the heat, met some neighbors. Was great having laundry to wash our clothes before we left. We will for sure be back.

DonnaVrboJul 2026
GuestAirbnbDec 2025

Conveniently located near shops and restaurants. Furnishings were somewhat outdated.

GuestAirbnbOct 2025

We thoroughly enjoyed our stay. Plenty of restaurants nearby. The owner said it was on a busy road, and that’s true, but we were not bothered by that. Very clean and up-to-date. We would stay there again. Conveniently located near Peninsula Park and walking/biking trails.

GuestAirbnbSep 2025

The location was great, adjacent to peninsula state park and walkable to Fish Creek restaurants. Unfortunately, the place was underwhelming. There were stains on the carpet, the fridge was falling apart, the toilet paper holder was coming off the wall and the mattresses were uncomfortable. Also, the pool was closed despite the near 80 degree weather. Kids were not happy.

GuestAirbnbSep 2025

The location is great. It’s a two minute walk to several trails at Peninsula State Park. It’s an easy walk to downtown Fish Creek as well. The unit was clean and had everything we needed. Would recommend staying here if you’re visiting Door County!

GuestAirbnbAug 2025

Great location. Quiet even tho next to street. Needs maintenance. Broken blinds. Front storm door closet broken. Major spider webs at front door. Stains on bedspread. Missing towel holder in upstairs bedroom. Downstairs toilet paper holder loose

GuestAirbnbAug 2025

The pullout in the living room was a single, not a two-person bed. The supplies were sparse. Location was great and easy to walk to restaurants and shops.

GuestAirbnbJul 2025

Nice place in a great location.

GuestAirbnbJul 2025

Great cozy location downtown Fish Creek. Great pool for kids. Was awesome all around BUT t was wayyyyyyy overpriced. Our other option cancelled last minute so we had to pay the price as it was the only option on airbnb for the dates but the price for the stay was offensive alas....

GuestAirbnbJul 2025

This is a great location in Fish Creek. Walking distance to shops and restaurants. Close to the water. The place was very clean and just as described.

GuestAirbnbJun 2025

Eveyone was so nice awesome pool clean house we loved it !!!

markVrboSep 2024

Great location Steps to the village!

JohannaVrboSep 2024

Fantastic location! We loved the yellow birch cottage. Perfect location, great spot and a pool for the kids. Will definitely be back!

CarolannVrboAug 2024

Door county summer trip Everything was as described, easy check in.

AnonymousVrboAug 2024

Great getaway Great location, very comfortable place. All the amenities of home, thanks for a great stay.

AnneVrboAug 2024

Would stay again. Fantastic location, wonderful property!

AnonymousVrboAug 2024

Great Time Great location

AnonymousVrboJul 2024

Convenient, comfortable and quiet. Was located close to all the activities, food, shops and beaches. Very quiet and private area. Hope to stay here again.

AnonymousVrboJun 2024

Almost perfect The cottage, its location, and our stay were outstanding. The communication was lousy-no response three separate occasions, which was disappointing and frustrating. We dinged the cleanliness score, also, because the carpets/rugs were FILTHY. The management can correct these issues if they care enough.

Check Availability & Book Direct

View rate calendar · Full listing · Reviews as of Oct 2026