Called In Sic — Guest Reviews

Prime Vacations - Anna Maria Island4 bedrooms3 bathsSleeps 8

Review Summary

Overall Rating
5.0 / 5
Total Reviews
6
Sources
Airbnb (3) · Vrbo (2)
Most Recent
May 2026

Each review shows: source · star rating · date · guest comments. Reviews are grouped by traveler type. Persona ratings reflect the average score from guests in that category.

All Reviews5.0 avg · 6 reviews
PaulAirbnbMay 2026

It was a pleasure hosting Paul! We hope to host them again in the future! Wonderful home and superb host! Great get away with family. highly recommended easy access to beach and plenty to do in home!

RohanAirbnbApr 2026

Rohan was a pleasure to host ! Great spot close to the north shore. Everything as described. Clean place, everything worked, nice location. We unfortunately didn’t get the best weather but loved that we had a pool and hot tub to enjoy. For future renters - the beaches on this side of the island are not as nice as the gulf side (nothing to do with the property) so it’s a 20-30 min walk across to the gulf side

JonathanAirbnbAug 2025

Thank you for choosing us for your recent stay! Every review and every star you give us makes a huge difference to our success. If you enjoyed your stay, we'd love your 5-star review! We hope to host you again in the future! Overall great place. Great location and great amenities. Place was clean and very comfortable. However, it needs umbrella's for beach essentials. We also noticed limited toiletries.

DevinAirbnbAug 2025

It was a pleasure hosting Devin! We hope to host them again in the future!

MichaelVrboMar 2024

Overall, “Called in Sic” was exactly as advertised. Situated in a quiet neighborhood, one block from the beach, the location couldn’t have been better. The roof deck was off the charts. 360 degree view for miles. The house was pristinely clean when we arrived. Communication with the rental company was prompt and extremely attentive. The pool provided both adequate shade as well as sun filled spots to lounge. The garage area was awesome, and a favorite of the kids in our group. The outdoor TV/lounge area was a great spot to hang out at night. A couple minor critiques, the construction next door was unfortunate, but unavoidable from the renters standpoint. The weekdays we stayed were filled with hammers and loud music from the construction crew from about 10am thru 5pm, and was noticeable if you were on the roof deck our out by the pool. We drowned out most of the noise with our own speaker, but definitely a downfall of being on an area of the island that has construction. The first night we stayed, we were excited to fire up the grill, only to find out the propane tanks were both empty. We contacted the rental company via text and there were 2 tanks delivered before we woke up the next day. We had to change our plans from grilling hamburgers to using the stove, which proved difficult with only one frying pan provided. Overall, everything was outstanding. We will look to book the same week next year, when the construction next door will be finished. Location unmatched

JessVrboFeb 2024

This house was perfect for a girls weekend away with family - plenty of room to spread out for 6 people. The pool was awesome - and we enjoyed the hot tub portion since we had cooler temps. 5 minute walk to a Bean Point beach entrance made for easy trips back and forth to the beach! Walk to town/trolley is ~15 minutes as well. The rooftop is such a great spot to relax with plenty of seating! Great communication with the property manager. We loved our stay at AMI and would rent here again!

Check Availability & Book Direct

View rate calendar · Full listing · Reviews as of May 2026