Blue Bay — Guest Reviews

Anna Maria Vacations8 bedrooms6 bathsSleeps 18

Review Summary

Overall Rating
4.2 / 5
Total Reviews
8
Sources
Airbnb (5)
Most Recent
May 2026

Each review shows: source · star rating · date · guest comments. Reviews are grouped by traveler type. Persona ratings reflect the average score from guests in that category.

All Reviews4.2 avg · 8 reviews
MimiAirbnbMay 2026

Mimi was a pleasure !

AlexAirbnbMar 2026

Alex was a pleasure to host Great rental home! Location was fabulous. Very close to restaurants/shops/etc. only trouble we had was keeping the hot tub warm but they were very responsive in fixing the problem!

SireeshaAirbnbSep 2025

Sireesha was a pleasure to host!

NatashaAirbnbApr 2025

Natasha was a pleasure! Great location with plenty of room for everyone to stay comfortably! Beautiful views of the ocean, close to everything and the pool area was great. Our only complaint was when we arrived the pool area was dirty and we found beads and a couple other trash items from previous guests in the pool but when I called the host, they were very helpful and sent someone to clean the pool the next day. With that being said, I would stay again and was pleased with our experience.

AntoniaAirbnbFeb 2025

Antonia was a pleasure to host! Loved our stay at AMI. Easy to contact and very prompt with any issues.

MeganAirbnbJan 2024

Megan, was a pleasure to host! Overall, the property was nice and in a good location. The property is good size for a large group. I lowered my score for a couple reasons. First, the property didn’t seem very clean when we arrived. The guest house had dirt everywhere and looked like it had not been cleaned and the main house had some of this as well. The furniture in the main living room had a lot of stains on it and simply looked dirty. Secondly, the pool/spa blower motor was out of commission and never got fixed. We noticed this right away when we arrived on Saturday and pool maintenance came on Sunday. The two gentleman told us the blower motor was not working and that a vendor would have to come fix. I received an update from AMI on Sunday and Monday that they were working to get in touch with a vendor and then later in the week the update switched to they were waiting on approval from the owner, which never came during our stay. For home much money we paid, would expect better.

NiranjanAirbnbDec 2023

Niranjan was a pleasure to host!

ValAirbnbOct 2023

When we checked in the cottage in the back was not accessible. They helped me to get in that day. We did have an issue with an alarm going off that would not stop and no one showed up till the next day which was a little disappointing, because it was very very loud. they did show up the next day and take care of it. Then the next day the air conditioning broke, and they did show up that day which was wonderful. The house was fantastic. The pool was not clean, but it was still usable. Otherwise everything else was fantastic. Would totally recommend this house.

Check Availability & Book Direct

View rate calendar · Full listing · Reviews as of May 2026