Book Downtown New Buffalo 5BR w Pool & Hot Tub

5 bedrooms · 10 beds · 2.5 bathrooms · Sleeps 14

House

Where you’ll sleep

King

Bedroom 1

King

Bedroom 2

Queen

Bedroom 3

2x Twin

Bedroom 4

King · 3x Twin · Sofa Bed

Bedroom 5

Spacious 5-Bedroom House in New Buffalo, Perfect for Large Groups

–Spacious 5-bedroom house perfect for large groups
–Comfortable accommodations for up to 14 guests
–Located in the scenic New Buffalo, Michigan

Built in 1887, 1887 Home is a storied brick home on Merchant Street, reimagined for modern Harbor Country getaways. A skylit chef’s kitchen, two dining spaces, and a cozy family room gather everyone together. The private pool, hot tub, fire pit, and outdoor shower set the scene for long sunny day...

About this property

Built in 1887, 1887 Home is a storied brick home on Merchant Street, reimagined for modern Harbor Country getaways. A skylit chef’s kitchen, two dining spaces, and a cozy family room gather everyone together. The private pool, hot tub, fire pit, and outdoor shower set the scene for long sunny days and starlit nights. With 5 bedrooms and 2.5 baths, a short walk to downtown New Buffalo’s shops and restaurants, and a 15-minute stroll to the beach, this is small town Michigan at its most charming.

Step through the front door into a bright shiplap entry, where vintage hall tree hooks and a painted console set a warm, storied tone. The heart of the home is a showpiece kitchen under a vaulted, beamed ceiling and skylights, with a navy island that seats six, a farmhouse sink, a gas range, and a wall of patterned tile. A breakfast nook with a cushioned bench overlooks the leafy front lawn, while a bar cart with stemware keeps happy hour within reach. Family dinners happen at a round pedestal table for six beneath a lantern chandelier. The family room rounds it out with a plush sofa, board games, a smart TV for movie nights, and sliding doors that open straight to the pool deck.

Five bedrooms across two levels give everyone a place to land, from the main floor king bedroom overlooking the rocking chair porch to the top floor loft, where kids and cousins can spread out with their own TV. Each room is dressed in crisp white linens and character pieces like a reclaimed wood bed and vintage painted dressers, setting the stage for slow mornings and deep sleep after long beach days.

Lower Level
Master Bedroom 1: King Bed
Upper Level
Bedroom 2: King Bed
Bedroom 3: Queen Bed
Bedroom 4: 2 Twin Beds
Loft Bedroom: King Bed, 3 Twin Beds and Pull-out couch

Two full baths and a half bath keep busy mornings moving. On the main floor, shiplap walls, a marble vanity, and a tub and shower wrapped in handmade green tile pair modern comfort with historic charm. Upstairs, a frameless glass shower with a teak bench, crisp subway tile, and black hex floors bring a boutique hotel feel. A rustic half bath sits just off the laundry room, where a full size washer and dryer and a keyless side entry from the driveway make sandy towels and swimsuits easy to handle. Fresh towels and an amenity kit are ready and waiting.

Life at 1887 Home spills outdoors, starting with a covered front porch lined with rocking chairs and a quiet side porch framed by wrought iron railings. The fenced backyard is a private retreat, with an inground pool, a bubbling hot tub, and a cedar outdoor shower for rinsing off after the beach. Fire up the grill for dinner at the patio table, claim the hammock, or gather around the stone fire pit as the string lights glow. A gravel drive and a sprawling side lawn shaded by mature oaks make this a rare find so close to town.

Step off the porch and you’re in the heart of New Buffalo. Stroll down Merchant Street to Brewster’s for Italian dinners on the patio, or slip into the Hummingbird Lounge for craft cocktails. Spend your days on the sandy shores of Lake Michigan at New Buffalo Beach, watching boats cruise in and out of the harbor. Browse the boutiques along Whittaker Street, sip your way through the Lake Michigan Shore Wine Trail, or hike the towering dunes at Warren Dunes State Park, all just a short drive or stroll away. Whatever the season, 1887 Home is the perfect home base for your Harbor Country getaway.

The area

1887 Home sits on a quiet, leafy stretch of Merchant Street, surrounded by historic homes just blocks from downtown New Buffalo. Mornings start on the porch rockers before a walk to the boutiques on Whittaker Street, and evenings end with dinner and drinks a short stroll away. New Buffalo Beach and the marina are about a 15-minute walk, perfect for sunset swims and watching the boats come home. It’s the best of both worlds: small town charm with all of Harbor Country right at your doorstep.

Notes from your host

To ensure a safe and compliant stay, all guests are required to complete identity verification prior to check-in. A valid government-issued photo ID will be collected and verified, and the name on the ID must match the credit card used for payment. When applicable, a background screening may also be required as part of the booking process.

All guests are required to review and sign Juniper Holiday + Home's Guest Occupancy Agreement prior to check-in. While we understand that events can affect your trip, it is our policy to stick to the agreed-upon cancellation policy in the listing. We recommend purchasing vacation travel insurance if you suspect you may need to cancel your reservation.

A non-refundable Accidental Damage Waiver is included with your reservation. This waiver covers accidental damage or loss to the rental property caused by you or members of your party, up to a maximum of $2,000. This plan does not cover intentional acts, gross negligence, or willful misconduct.

The minimum age to rent this home is 25.

The pool is seasonal and will be open from Memorial Day Weekend - Labor Day. Specific Open and closure dates are scheduled by the local pool vendor.

Pets are not allowed at this property.

Out of respect for our staff and their families, we do not permit check-ins or check-outs on Thanksgiving Day and Christmas Day. Thank you for your understanding.

full description, the area, host notes

Managed by Juniper Holiday + Home

Union Pier, Michigan

4.7★

1,065 reviews

A curated collection of luxury vacation rentals across Southwest Michigan, Indiana, Whitefish, and Florida. Book direct from a design-led local team for worry-free stays rooted in genuine hospitality.

Browse all 103 properties

juniperholidayandhome.com